ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

undoubtedly Harris Jeyaraj / YSR 8-)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by njv

anand

chaiyya chaiya and another MSV song in the same movie.

Even YSR is not leaving anyone alone. In Vallavan for one of the song, he copied IR, ARR (Errani song beat from Kadhalan is used), some english movie (not sure which one, HP I believe) and MSV and TR, all in 1 song.

I watched his interview recently - he said to score music for movies, we dont need to have any formal musical knowledge - Ippa puriyudhu yennu - Ivaru IR magannu sonna IRkku maha kevalam.

Guys, MSV, IR, ARR - Thats it. Nothing else to discuss. Wait for another one to come in next decade.

---

:clap: :clap: :clap: :yes: :yes: :yes: superrr sir :ty: ithaithan naan soolanu innu nenachin.aani adichappala sollitingga..M.S.V.IR.ARR piragu adutha idam innum kaaliyathan irukku!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bulb_mani

undoubtedly Harris Jeyaraj / YSR 8-)

---

unnga aasaiya naan yaan kedukkanum :lol: :lol: :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bulb_mani

undoubtedly Harris Jeyaraj / YSR 8-)

---

no way, a person who will come from 7 mountains and 7 seas like a monster wave who will wash away HJ/YSR/GVP and the IR trend,ARR trend.... :lol:

we dont need to have any formal musical knowledge -ysr
uthumathiri arr ethavathu interviewla sonna enna agum konjam nenachu parrunnga sir!!!
raja sir sandaikku vanthuruvar :lol:

Guru vs. Pachaikilli Muthucharam vs. Chennai 600028

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by baba88

Guru vs. Pachaikilli Muthucharam vs. Chennai 600028

---

Original vs rehash vs remix

All may be good. Guru (in hindi) will stand outstanding.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by njv

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by baba88

Guru vs. Pachaikilli Muthucharam vs. Chennai 600028

---

Original vs rehash vs remix

All may be good. Guru (in hindi) will stand outstanding.

---

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by njv

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by baba88

Guru vs. Pachaikilli Muthucharam vs. Chennai 600028

---

Original vs rehash vs remix

All may be good. Guru (in hindi) will stand outstanding.

---

omg... hahahaah.... :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: couldnt agree more.....

I think YSR is right in what he says. Classical music gives you a method to compose for movies but not THE ONLY way. A MD does not do classical performance in movies, he presents a set of songs that suits the theme of a particular movie. Is there any rule he should compose only based on raagas (unless it is sindu bairavi or ....)? If you have the technical knowledge and a song is composed based on some raaga, you will enjoy it more. But as a commoner, I don't think it matters much as long as the song is good to listen. If you are expecting only classical based songs from movies, then you should be dumb. Don't blame the MD, because that is not their job. :)

In his recent interview to AV, Sanjay Subramiam says that he likes IR songs that came out before IR started using raagas into his film songs. Does that tell you anything??