Printable View
people, just for your kind information....
To do a remix song, its not being proposed by the Music Director but it is by the Film Director that applies to the script of the movie...
there is no need to blame Yuvan...
He is just doing his job and doing it best...
If people dont like remix then just dont listen to it...
In the end people will have to complain about different music directors composition, and the argument starts there again...
people, just for your kind information....
To do a remix song, its not being proposed by the Music Director but it is by the Film Director that applies to the script of the movie...
there is no need to blame Yuvan...
He is just doing his job and doing it best...
If people dont like remix then just dont listen to it...
In the end people will have to complain about different music directors composition, and the argument starts there again...
people, just for your kind information....
To do a remix song, its not being proposed by the Music Director but it is by the Film Director that applies to the script of the movie...
there is no need to blame Yuvan...
He is just doing his job and doing it best...
If people dont like remix then just dont listen to it...
In the end people will have to complain about different music directors composition, and the argument starts there again...
"actually I dont have the technical knowledge. but whats wrong with "kanda naal mudhalai" song??? I think it is very good song. it has carnatic feel in tune and has techno BGM. is there any rule like for carnatic tune, we should use only carnatic instruments?
if i am wrong, then point out. "
I said the song was a remix (of a an already existing carnatic composition) and not an original composition. Thats it. I didnt say anything was wrong or right with it. If you like that song maybe you should request YSR to remix more.
think about it... do u see other MDs does remix as much as YSR ??? what is so special in movies worked by YSR that needs Remix badly...??!! apadi parthal...the movie BOYS would need 80 % remix.... did we have any remix there?!!Quote:
Originally Posted by sentsbu1
its easy to blame the dirs on every aspect,but wut the md is good at,that is what the dir will ask for his movie... and if its the public's fav,then they somehow will make the song fit for the movie...
Seriously, remixes are reducing a lot of credibility out of yuvan........why cant he say a NO to the directors who demand it??? when he can demand a salary as much as ARR then i dont think he is any more a small guy in the industry.....
judge, y do u have to take refugee in IR whenever a finger is pointed at u1??? doesent u1 have his own compositions??? btw, ARR's comeback is pretty well set i guess.......judge, get ready for the ARR onslaught in 2007...... 8-)
>>>>>
So lets keep the standards uniform.
<<<<<
Was just wondering if you gave the "kaNda nAL mudhal" type of comment when alaipAyudhE was released.
IMO, both alaipAyuthE and kaNda nAL didn't tamper the inherent beauty of the original numbers in any way.
FYI, we dont consider Alaipauthey song as his composition any day..........infact it was the last hit in that album below Yaaro yaarodi and evano oruvan.......Quote:
Originally Posted by Shankar
how does it matter? This discussion is about YSR, not ARR. In case you missed it, I have acknowledged that Alaipaayudhe had been reused just 2 posts back. But I dont find the need to drag ARR in every discussion of YSR, like how some guys like you are itching to do here.Quote:
Originally Posted by Shankar
Also Alaipaayudhe is a song that has been used as such without too much instrumental intrusion. Its mostly vocals with minimal accompaniment and no interludes. So Iam not sure if it can be even called a remix technically. Plus in Rahman's case,knowing that he is strictly against remixing(when SJ Surya asked him to remix thottal poo malarum, Rahman asked him to take a hike) I dont consider this as remixing but more of a faithful reproduction of the original,which even many older MDs have done(saamaja vara gamana, brova baarama, mahagaNapathim etc.) More of a direct tribute than remixing.