ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

>>>>>
like how some guys like you are itching to do here.
<<<<<

I wasn't involved in the discussion in any way here...When I saw an obvious bias I posted a response. Nobody is itching to foul mouth arr. You can respond to my post and stop with that and not play smart by criticizing me.

>>>>>
I dont consider this as remixing but more of a faithful reproduction of the original,which even many older MDs have done(saamaja vara gamana, brova baarama, mahagaNapathim etc.) More of a direct tribute than remixing.
<<<<<

In that case KNM is also a 'faithful' repro of the original. Comparing alaipayuthE and samaja vara gamana ?!hmm...interesting.

Maddy,
Nobody's questioning arr's version of alaipAyuthE...I liked it too...but calling KNM a 'remix' and this a 'faithful repro' had me in splits :-)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

Seriously, remixes are reducing a lot of credibility out of yuvan........why cant he say a NO to the directors who demand it??? when he can demand a salary as much as ARR then i dont think he is any more a small guy in the industry.....

judge, y do u have to take refugee in IR whenever a finger is pointed at u1??? doesent u1 have his own compositions??? btw, ARR's comeback is pretty well set i guess.......judge, get ready for the ARR onslaught in 2007...... 8-)

---

YSR's remixes have let him down. Now even some mediocre MDs like Imman have started to do the same. Atleast now YSR shud stop remixing.

In terms of salary he is no whre near ARR, Maddy. ARR is pocketing 1.5 crores whereas YSR gets 50 lacs.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vijayr

I dont consider this as remixing but more of a faithful reproduction of the original,which even many older MDs have done.

---

ARR senja faithful reproduction of the original, yuvan senja remix. Nalla niyayam. :wave: :wave:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ajaybaskar

YSR's remixes have let him down. Now even some mediocre MDs like Imman have started to do the same. Atleast now YSR shud stop remixing.

In terms of salary he is no whre near ARR, Maddy. ARR is pocketing 1.5 crores whereas YSR gets 50 lacs.

---

yes. u1 should stop this. if he says no to vishnu and simbu, then problem is solved. because the 2 peoples only asking remixes. u1 did 90% remixes only for these people.

then i read somewhere that u1's salary is 70 lacs.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vasanth2006

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vijayr

I dont consider this as remixing but more of a faithful reproduction of the original,which even many older MDs have done.

---

ARR senja faithful reproduction of the original, yuvan senja remix. Nalla niyayam. :wave: :wave:

---

do u mean to say IR remixed "maha ganapathim" in sindhu bharavi??? no vasanth, theres a lot of diff betn ARR's works and YSR's......anyways, best of luck to u1 for watever he does.......afterall we need new ideas/new sounds coming in TFM.... :D

ajay, ARR has slashed his salary a lot for tamil.....he takes only around 90lacs.....YSR is around 75 lacs some 6 months back.......he shuld be touching 90 now easily.....

In hindi, ARR demands upto 2 crores....... 8-)

"I wasn't involved in the discussion in any way here...When I saw an obvious bias I posted a response. Nobody is itching to foul mouth arr. You can respond to my post and stop with that and not play smart by criticizing me.
"

uNmaiya sonna kovam varudho? :-)


"I wasn't involved in the discussion in any way here...When I saw an obvious bias I posted a response. Nobody is itching to foul mouth arr. You can respond to my post and stop with that and not play smart by criticizing me."

if anyone around here is biased its you. I clearly acknowledged that Alaipaayudhge was remixed/reused. In fact I was the one who brought it up few posts back in a reply to Mr. Judge's post.

Obviously you missed it, or couldnt comprehend. Parava illa.

Whereas you pointed out that Mellisaye Mellisaye was lifted the other day, which was laughable :-) (there was hardly any resemblance) and yet 7GRC Rainbow theme should be excused because only one motif was lifted :-) :-) who is being biased here?

I termed Alaipaayudhe as a remixed song to be fair here in this discussion, but I said PERSONALLy I think its MORE of a faithful reproduction than remix,which doesnt mean its completely a faithful reproduction, but closer ot it than a remix. Once again poor comprehension on your part. KaNda naaL mudhal had interludes and an (annoying) rhythm pattern added to it to make it light. So it definitely wasnt a faithful reproduction of the original. Alaipaayudhe was mostly vocals, it didnt have any annoying interludes.
Will you say MahagaNaapthaim was remixed too by IR,as it had IR's own violin interludes? :-)

>>>>>
Mellisaye Mellisaye was lifted the other day, which was laughable
<<<<<

Well...You can laugh, but that's all you can do...You can take away the fact that MellisayE had a few phrases directly lifted from Bolero. I can send you the sheet if you can read it. Ask our common friend to play it for you in his keyboard...You'll know.

>>>>>>
Also Alaipaayudhe is a song that has been used as such without too much instrumental intrusion. Its mostly vocals with minimal accompaniment and no interludes. So Iam not sure if it can be even called a remix technically.
<<<<<
I termed Alaipaayudhe as a remixed song to be fair here in this discussion, but I said PERSONALLy I think its MORE of a faithful reproduction than remix,which doesnt mean its completely a faithful reproduction, but closer ot it than a remix.
>>>>>

Not sure if this is comprehension problem of one or the lack of articulation from the other. You decide, since you give the opinion of the universe, unless stated explicitly :-)