Discussions on R.Madhavan Pt 4

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Plum

Not that I will act all pious and demand that NT cannot be spoofed but this was downright silly, idiotic, tasteless and completely lacking in entertainment.

---

but to be frank, pattaabi replicated SG of pudhiya paravai... u can see SG's walk, style, look everything in pattabi.

Note:- Pattabi is MS Bhasker, SG is Sivaji ganeshan 8-)

Oh MS Bhaskar is talented alright. But the lines given, the scenarios given everything was tasteless and Bhaskar is not talented enough to rise above all that.

Vivek kooda 'merge' agitathaala avarukkum fancy dress competion vyaathi thothikichi.. Barath pilim la kooda etho balram naidu getup la varuvaar.. :x

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Plum

Oh MS Bhaskar is talented alright. But the lines given, the scenarios given everything was tasteless and Bhaskar is not talented enough to rise above all that.

---

largely goundamani act(in the name of comedy) is tasteless. but few people do enjoy.
whats the problem if Vivek and MS do certain things(tasteless for likes of u) in the name of comedy ???????

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dinesh84

Vivek kooda 'merge' agitathaala avarukkum fancy dress competion vyaathi thothikichi.. Barath pilim la kooda etho balram naidu getup la varuvaar.. :x

---

:lol:
balramnaidu getup'la var'radhu vivek 8-)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sarna

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Plum

Oh MS Bhaskar is talented alright. But the lines given, the scenarios given everything was tasteless and Bhaskar is not talented enough to rise above all that.

---

largely goundamani act(in the name of comedy) is tasteless. but few people do enjoy.
whats the problem if Vivek and MS do certain things(tasteless for likes of u) in the name of comedy ???????

---

Hmm.. adhu oru karuthu. However, if you cannot differentiate between irreverent social satire and tasteless, entertainment less parody of a spoof, good for you :-)

As you can notice, what I have carefully said is that Bhaskar doesnt rise above the tastelessness of it and carry it through. I am fine with the idea, but execution was horrid. It requires sharper lines, and better acting to actually make even tasteless comedy funny and watchable.

For instance, Vivek does NT act frequently, and very often, insultingly, but sometimes it does click - like the Parasakthi Court scene, and even RaasakkapALayam ("enadhu kaNgaL..." was hilarious in NT accent, and his reaction to Ranjit praising him in his letter to his mother was superb) was not bad. But this Pudhiya Paravai act just wasnt funny at all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Plum

But this Pudhiya Paravai act just wasnt funny at all.

---

modhallayE idha solli irukkalaam :)

but first u came up with unwarranted things like absolute nonsense, downright silly, idiotic, tasteless etc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Plum

if you cannot differentiate between irreverent social satire and tasteless, entertainment less parody of a spoof, good for you

---

i know to differentiate and i do enjoy few goundamani comedies... but I never enjoy so called gounderisms like "sangoodhura vayasula sangeetha" can be defined in ur words like absolute nonsense, downright silly, idiotic, tasteless etc

sarNA, I'd prefer if you say out aloud that Gounder act is tasteless and allow me to say the same of Pudhiya Paravai parody :-)

idhu oru karuthu, adhu oru karuthu avLO dhAn!

naan ennamo ninaichaa inga ennamo nadakuthae :lol2:

I agree with Plum on the spoofing. I would really enjoy making fun of who ever may be.. Fun ngra paerla panra ellaame fun aa irukirathila..rather irritating..

example is this vivek and MSB spoofing on Shivaji and Saroja :sigh2:

Singam padathula koodaa, appaa nallavaraa kettavaraannu ithukku munnaala 1000 times spoof pannappatta Nayagan dialogue.. But antha place within a family daughter, mom and dad related aa family kulla chinna chinna jokes ngra muraila enjoy panra maathiri irukkum..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Plum

sarNA, I'd prefer if you say out aloud that Gounder act is tasteless and allow me to say the same of Pudhiya Paravai parody :-)

---

Plum, if u say that likes of "sangoodhu vayasa sangeedha" is gounderism and name it as irreverent social satire, then I'd say out aloud that gounderism(or gounder act or whatever u call) is absolute nonsense, downright silly, idiotic, tasteless etc