ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrJudge

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vijayr

"Did you ridicule arr too when he remixed 'mangalyam thanthu naane' bit in alaipayuthey?"

That was an original tune, it was not a remix. Guess you probably dont even realize the difference. The alaipaayudhe title song was what that was re-used.

---

I don't know about the title song, I haven't watched the full movie yet. I have watched it only in bits and pieces. But I vaguely remember that there is this background song (mangalyam thanthu... with usual tune but with modern beats) during the marriage scene. and AV was praising it. As I clearly said that I am not sure about it. Generally is it really hard to understand remix and original tunes?

---

omgoodnes... u ignorant dude,the Mangalyam Tantuna .... in AlaiPayuthey had basic Endredrum Punnagai tune & a diff tempo beats... have u ever even heard the real Mangalyam tune ?? gosh...

http://www.musicindiaonline.com/p/x/...FCS.As1NMvHdW/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrJudge

I guess you have technical knowledge but that does not stop you from making wrong judgements. If you are so confident about those mds classical based compositions, just quote me one classical based tamil album on par with SB from these guys.

---

ARR has done a classical based tamil album..which is not very classical type but very nice to listen to and a excellent effort as well...sangamam had mazhai thuli(this is classical folk used for stories and for god glorification)...Margazhi thingal(excellent classical melody)...and Sowkiyama kanne was pure classical at its best

As for VS he has given us many classical based compositions which can match up to IR but sadly he has been ignored too much when there is a need for classical albums in tamil. But VS has scored a classical album and received a national award as well with Swara-abishegam(telugu)

"Mr. Judge"kku therinjadhu avvlodhaan..vidunga. He is not going to change. Iam done with this topic.

"But VS has scored a classical album and received a national award as well with Swara-abishegam(telugu)"

I forgot about that album. Thanks for mentioning it.

No problem :D..i feel Mr Judge does know about ARR and VS talents..just that he hates ARR alot which i cant decipher. :confused2:

judge is not a YSR fan also...he is just a ARR hater... he has some vengeance on ARR or ARR fans in TFM page avlothan..... ask him directly what makes him hate ARR and then he will change track and talk about something else :)

rsubras, that explains it.

How could we say YSR squandered away the opportunity to score a carnatic song? Just like ARR used "Alaipayudhe" to suit the title[May be Mani's choice], YSR might have used "Kanda naaL mudhalai" again to suit the movie title[may be on Dir Priya's insistence. She happens to be Mani's protege]. Anyway IMO I welcome these tamil keerthanai in TFM as the common mass like me would get to know these precious gems atleast through films.

and KNM is not a SindhuBairavi either

Thumburu sir YSR is yet to do a full classical album yet..or a album with classical tunes...so we cant really say how talented he is..as for now he seems to be more towards westernised music but even that as well has abit of very strong R and B influence from american artists. I hope yuvan can do a classical album..it does not have to be pure but as long as its original and there is some uniqueness we can have a idea about his talent :D

Although Yuvan seems to be suspect in giving a classical song, his recent other numbers are very good. Well orchestrated and well packaged. In fact, the single biggest factor for a hit song is excellent packaging. It doesn't seem to matter if there is a hint of other songs, as long as the flow is good and the music is catchy to the ears. Harris does this particularly well, followed by Yuvan and to a little extent even Imman.