ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

G Ramanathan...is he the one who composed manmadha leelaiyai vendruvar undo? I only have listened to that song but due to quality problems have not heard much of his songs...but i do know about KVM...i only listened to his classical and semi classical albums...he always uses the veenai brilliantly either in the prelude or interlude...at times sound so bhakthi like :exactly:

i think yuvan has a unique style atleast in instumentation...

Not really....he uses R and B style of loops in his instrumentation but before that his music was a patch off ARR with some fluidity of his own. Atleast now he is abit innovative and starting to compose his own style although the influence is still there :D

>>>>>>
I can imagine Srikanth Deva or Sabesh Murali
<<<<<<

Nov,
I am not a major admirer of SD or SB...However, they shouldn't be thought as a people who can be used like a 'default' case in C :-)(if you have none to compare, bring them in types).
I have read interviews of SD and seen an interview of Sabesh, and IMO they are humble guys and they clearly know that they aren't in the league of the biggies. They haven't foul mouthed anyone AFAIK.

Their musical abilities may be limited, but you cannot extend that to their personality.

IMO, MSV-Raja-ARR have their own style, and they clearly set the trends of their age. The rest aren't trend setters of any sort.

...and G Ramanatha Iyer before that. He was just awesome.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hulkster

Not really....he uses R and B style of loops in his instrumentation but before that his music was a patch off ARR with some fluidity of his own. Atleast now he is abit innovative and starting to compose his own style although the influence is still there :D

---

see he himself has said "after ir and arr noone can make a separate trend in music"

its common to have either ir style or arrs

but what he should stois remixing songs...he could provide better songs than "my name is billa" and "vethalaya potendi"

why did he remix...and his copying songs ...he must stop that!

its not a problem to have arr style in his music...but atleast tune must be completely original

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shankar

>>>>>>
I can imagine Srikanth Deva or Sabesh Murali
<<<<<<

Nov,
I am not a major admirer of SD or SB...However, they shouldn't be thought as a people who can be used like a 'default' case in C :-)(if you have none to compare, bring them in types).
I have read interviews of SD and seen an interview of Sabesh, and IMO they are humble guys and they clearly know that they aren't in the league of the biggies. They haven't foul mouthed anyone AFAIK.

Their musical abilities may be limited, but you cannot extend that to their personality.

---

ejatly...their family isso humble...devas interview shows he is so frank and humble :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hulkster

G Ramanathan...is he the one who composed manmadha leelaiyai vendruvar undo?

---

yes, that and more.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Manisekaran

G. Ramanathan, SV VEngkatraman and CR Subbaraman are still called the "Thamizh thirai Isayin Mummoorthikal". The only film that had all these three genius composers working together is "Parijatham" They were all genius in their own ways, but SVV and CRS acknowledged GR as the "Isai Methai".

---

read more in Memories of Yesteryear section.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shankar

I am not a major admirer of SD or SB...However, they shouldn't be thought as a people who can be used like a 'default' case in C :-)(if you have none to compare, bring them in types).

---

:notworthy:
you are absolutely right of course. it was said in lighter vein. :D