ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hulkster

Thillana Mohanambal was folk with classical...:P....but i liked his other movies like karnan....mahakavi kalidass...thiruvilaiyaadal...aathi parashakthi...shakthi leelai. The instrumentation in there was breathtaking...seringa NOV..i will go and take a look :cool: :D

---

Hulkster, Karnan was by MSV - a top class score

NOV-point taken

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vijayr

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hulkster

Thillana Mohanambal was folk with classical...:P....but i liked his other movies like karnan....mahakavi kalidass...thiruvilaiyaadal...aathi parashakthi...shakthi leelai. The instrumentation in there was breathtaking...seringa NOV..i will go and take a look :cool: :D

---

Hulkster, Karnan was by MSV - a top class score

---

ofcourse a top class score...and a class movie

MSV ah :shock:....i guess i presumed KVM did most classical and epic based movies :oops:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NOV

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dinesh2002

i loved KVM's Thillana Moganambal ..... 1 of the greatest score in TFM..... :wink:

---

it thrills me to no end when the younger generation (you are 17?) begin to appreciate older compositions. :2thumbsup:

really there are treasures left behind by our forefathers and you will never stop being amazed by how much they have done with so little in hand.

---

oh Yes Nov.... i was very very impressed with many old compositions....esp KVM's & MSV's..... oh my god...those compositions r just too good to ignore.... what tunes & wut arrangments.... :D

dig:

dinesh,not just classical, MSV ventured into Jazz, rock n roll and what not. Just to casually mention one example listen to the song rock'n' roll from Pathibhakthi here
http://www.musicindiaonline.com/musi..._director.870/

the song switches between classical and rocknroll throughout. Can we say.... freakish? This was in the late 50s.

>>>>
of which you know nothing much
<<<<

Yeah, right ! You were the one who rejected my sheet reading abilities when you tested me.

You don't even know who I am, what my BG is. Why talk like a know-all when you don't even know the credentials of the other.

If you think similarity is at the meter level, then you need more friends to point things to you.

NOV,
Agreed. I am not discussing this any further.

It is nice that NOV brought KVM, GR, and others. All of them were awesome. Dinesh, there is a treasure to be unearthed by young folks like you. Listen to those gems and enjoy. Also listen to KVM's songs like "unnai arindhal nee unnai arindhal" (Vettaikaran?) and "Pattu selai kaathaada paruva meni koothaada" and "siriththu siriththu ennai siraiyil ittai" etc.

[quote="Shankar"]
Yeah, right ! You were the one who rejected my sheet reading abilities when you tested me.

You don't even know who I am, what my BG is. Why talk like a know-all when you don't even know the credentials of the other."

Please, dont make up stuff. All I said was that I didnt need the sheet.
And YOU were the one who said:

Quote:

---

"Well...You can laugh, but that's all you can do...You can take away the fact that MellisayE had a few phrases directly lifted from Bolero. I can send you the sheet if you can read it. Ask our common friend to

Quote:

---

play it for you in his keyboard

---

...You'll know."

---

so you assumed that someone has to play it on the keyboard for me to figure out and wondered about my sheet reading abilities.
And you didnt know my BG. So I should be the one telling you all the above comments :-) Instead,I have to listen to it from you. Funny.

Anyways lets end it here.

and this is the original post:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shankar

mellisai from Mr. Romeo is inspired from a classical music piece Bolero (Ravel)...I was playing this classical CD, and when Bolero started, i realized the first 6 bars are copied, and of course, after that the tune takes its own course.

But the main melody (the flute motif, and the beginning of the stanzas) are definitely lifted from Bolero.

---

so you realized that it was a lift as soon as it started playing. You didnt refer to any scoresheet to verify it. Then why talk about sheets and stuff to others unnecessarily? Understand there are other people who can do the same, that is identify a copy or inspiration, just by listening. They dont need to resort to KBs or scoresheets. Second, you dont have scoresheets of both the songs to compare,only one. So its a meaningless proposition.