ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

Sanjeevi, It would be early to say YSR would beat ARR. As I said before in my early post, a person who comes up with unique sound will beat ARR not YSR who mixes IR and ARR music and that is not unique. Yes Deva did that too in some of his movies and he started mixing IR style with modern beats and mixing IR and ARR but for a short time with no luck.

I dont see any uniqueness in YSR music. He has started using lot more spanish, middle eastern music thats all...Probably new to Tamilians but not to Indians.

YSR is hot and happening, and deserves it...

Atleast he doesnt impersonate his dad or arr ... he has his own style...... he has his own self respect unlike some other goof!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Movies

number two currently is a tie between YSR and VS. IVS cause he has shown his talent and strength in all sorts of composition, ranging from classical to dapanguthu. He is one guy that desperatley need media attention. Poor fellow is being ignored in all corners! YSR cause , i have to admit his songs are the peppiest since arr decided to make experiments his routine. He is a master of mixing.... but he falls short with his copying instincts and lack of shelf life his songs are really good at the time .. but thats it... the songs are highly dpendent on the movies success...... must also add the media and the humungous success of his latest movies have made me like him.

---

VS? just watched the movie Ponniyin selvan. Songs are just trash, and he copied beats from deven magan song, oomai vizhigal song and repeated from his own gilli. BGM is just bad. I don't know why Radha mohan left Ramesh vinayagam and went to VS. He may be good at giving classical based numbers but film music scores need not to have classical flavor. And I don't think he is consistent either. He needs tharani very badly to come up with hits.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by alias

Sanjeevi, It would be early to say YSR would beat ARR. As I said before in my early post, a person who comes up with unique sound will beat ARR not YSR who mixes IR and ARR music and that is not unique. Yes Deva did that too in some of his movies and he started mixing IR style with modern beats and mixing IR and ARR but for a short time with no luck.

I dont see any uniqueness in YSR music. He has started using lot more spanish, middle eastern music thats all...Probably new to Tamilians but not to Indians.

---

YSR is giving music in his own style inwhich you find styles IR and ARR. This not YSR mistakes, your mistake. Plus and Plus means Plus Plus.

Mr Judge,

Not that the other guys are clean... every one from VS to YSR to sirpi all copy and lack in various parts..... thats why they arent ARR or IR.........

But nevertheless... VS is good man... he can come up with classy stuffs and look at his mass songs..... what else does tamil movies need?... Thats what every MD is doing!

any idea abt ramesh vinayagams next film project?

hi movies,
lets forg the past differences we have had abt a aha songs. sorry abt that. lets keep in touch with lively comments and make the thread interesting.
appreciate if you will reply

Audio Review : 'Thotti Jaya' music decent - but not an 'Ah Aah'

Printer friendly page

Producer: Kalaippuli S Thanu
Director: V Z Durai
Cast: Silambarasan, Gopika
Music: Harris Jayaraj
Singers: Ranjith, Saindhavi, Shankar Mahadevan, Harris Jeyaraj, Anuradha Sriram, Bombay Jayashree, Karthik, Ceylon Manohar, Srilekha, Sriram Parthasarathy, Harini, Ramesh Vinayagam


Harris Jayaraj, once an assistant to A.R. Rahman, is today a music director in his own right. But while his compositions for "Thotti Jaya" are good, he loses this round to his mentor.

The album is a decent collection of songs that you could buy - if you have money left after purchasing "Ah...Aah", the latest by Rahman.
It starts off with Jayaraj composing a track which more than strongly resembles one of Rahman's compositions from the movie "Mudhalvan". Since the latter sounded really nice, this sounds quite enjoyable as well.

Most Rahman tracks have to be listened to several times before one begins to fall in love with them. Not so with Jayaraj. He proves that he can get the listener to like a song straightaway with "Uyire En Uyire" - though it begins to wear one out with its repetitiveness after a while.

Karthik's voice sounds terribly flat; and the less said of Anuradha Sreeram's rendition of the song the better.


As one begins to listen to the next track, one gets the feeling that Jayaraj's music seems to improve with every passing track. "Thotta Power" is a typically koothu number, the kind that is likely to get young men all around Tamil Nadu on their feet. Shankar Mahadevan does a typically brilliant job.

Side B starts off with "Yaaridamum", a typically romantic number with some energetic vocals from Ramesh Vinayagan and Harini. This is the kind of song that one may find oneself humming without realising it!

The last track in the album is "Jaari Singari", another koothu number.

The verdict on the track? Typical of most Tamil movies, and can be enjoyed if the listener can keep lurid images out of his mind.


© Copyright 2005 by MusicIndiaOnLine.com


http://www.musicindiaonline.com/ar/i/movie_name/7352/0/

Top 10 - Ghazini No 1 - Raaga.com

http://raaga.com/channels/tamil/top10.asp


Top 10 - Ah Aah No 1 - Musicindiaonline.com

http://www.musicindiaonline.com/l/ut/s/26/10/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Movies

Mr Judge,

Not that the other guys are clean... every one from VS to YSR to sirpi all copy and lack in various parts..... thats why they arent ARR or IR.........

But nevertheless... VS is good man... he can come up with classy stuffs and look at his mass songs..... what else does tamil movies need?... Thats what every MD is doing!

---

Hey.... did I ever say all others are clean? even IR and ARR have their shares. My point is after gilli, i haven't seen his hits. (maduray was ok and chandramuki - rajini factor) He is best with Dharani. All other his movies(ji, kana kandein, sathurangam didn't click well) And this year YSR and HJ lead the pack, not VS. PS's bgm is very bad. (Ramesh vinayagam gave couple of beautiful numbers in azagiya theeya) I don't think he will be a competitor for top spot in tfm. BTW, who is the md for dharani's latest telugu flick?VS?