Continuing on our efforts to decode Raja (not fossible but ...)
There are not many movies wherein the MD uses the same raga or its close cousin to convey different emotions. I am not talking about the same song sung in happy and sad mood. Those were 'bahe haat ka khel' for our older MDs. (For those who don't know Hindi, it means they could do it with their left hand.) Raja, his predecessors and his successors have done those. I am thinking of two totally different songs from the same movie having the same raga (or a very closely allied raga) but giving rise to totally different emotional experience.
I will not list 'Sundari' and 'Yamunai Atrile' from Dhalapathi (both based on Kalyani / Yamuna Kalyani) here since both are love songs.
The one movie where I saw Raja use Mayamalavagowla and the closely allied raga, Vakulabaranam, was in the Malayalam movie, 'Ponmudipuzhayorathu'. Mayamalavagowla is used in the highly popular 'oru chiri kandal'. This is a typical love song.
Check this out at:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qwG7li3mkQA
Raja, in the same movie, uses Vakulabaranam, which sounds very close to Mayamalavagowla and creates a totally different feel. The song is 'Ammayennu Vaaku'. Listen to it at:
http://www.raaga.com/channels/malaya...arch_fld=ALBUM
I thought that this was the first time he was doing this but saw that he also does this in Karagatakkakari.
http://www.thiraipaadal.com/albums/ALBIRR00276.html
Please check out the songs 'enna petha' in which Raja sings a philosophical song based on Mayamalavagowla and Tippu and Manjari sing 'EngaOoru' which seems to be based on Vakulabaranam. Here he inverts the emotions. In 'Ponmudipuzhayorathu', Mayamalavagowla is used for love and Vakulabaranam for giving a philosophical slant whereas in 'Karagatakkari' he does the opposite.
Has Raja tried something like this in 80s? Will be nice to know.