Album of the week

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thineshan54321

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thineshan54321

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by littlemaster1982

DM,

Kamal nadikkalainna Thenali album patthi unga karutthu enna ;)

---

athey karuthu thaan LM..

Infact, Puthiya Mugam is one of my most favourite albums ever.. athula mattum kamal nadichaaraa enna :huh:

---

then why the ARR bashing? :? infact, ur name (DM) has almost become synonymous to ARR-basher,anti-arr, etc, etc.

---

i am just constructively criticising ARR ....

ARR enna thappe pannamaataaraa enna :huh: singing seri illai , avaru songs-la.. atha sonnaa ennapaa tappu??

---

the only posts that i read from you other than the last few :? were all negatives. thats not constructive criticism, i mean who are you trying to "construct" with ur criticisms? according to me a critic is someone who throws in positives as well as negatives. when you just spit out negatives, then u r no longer a critic and no one will even pay attention to ur negatives, and ppl like us will only oppose it.

---

already, there is a lot of people here to point out the positives of ARR.. so only i am bringing out the negative side of him.. Cover-up panna yaaravathu try pannaa, naan vanthu matter-a open pannuven.. :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thineshan54321

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thineshan54321

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by littlemaster1982

DM,

Kamal nadikkalainna Thenali album patthi unga karutthu enna ;)

---

athey karuthu thaan LM..

Infact, Puthiya Mugam is one of my most favourite albums ever.. athula mattum kamal nadichaaraa enna :huh:

---

then why the ARR bashing? :? infact, ur name (DM) has almost become synonymous to ARR-basher,anti-arr, etc, etc.

---

i am just constructively criticising ARR ....

ARR enna thappe pannamaataaraa enna :huh: singing seri illai , avaru songs-la.. atha sonnaa ennapaa tappu??

---

the only posts that i read from you other than the last few :? were all negatives. thats not constructive criticism, i mean who are you trying to "construct" with ur criticisms? according to me a critic is someone who throws in positives as well as negatives. when you just spit out negatives, then u r no longer a critic and no one will even pay attention to ur negatives, and ppl like us will only oppose it.

---

already, there is a lot of people here to point out the positives of ARR.. so only i am bringing out the negative side of him.. Cover-up panna yaaravathu try pannaa, naan vanthu matter-a open pannuven.. :P

---

But you must remember there are also more negative sides with kamal and ilayaraja. 8-)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prasana84

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thineshan54321

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thineshan54321

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by littlemaster1982

DM,

Kamal nadikkalainna Thenali album patthi unga karutthu enna ;)

---

athey karuthu thaan LM..

Infact, Puthiya Mugam is one of my most favourite albums ever.. athula mattum kamal nadichaaraa enna :huh:

---

then why the ARR bashing? :? infact, ur name (DM) has almost become synonymous to ARR-basher,anti-arr, etc, etc.

---

i am just constructively criticising ARR ....

ARR enna thappe pannamaataaraa enna :huh: singing seri illai , avaru songs-la.. atha sonnaa ennapaa tappu??

---

the only posts that i read from you other than the last few :? were all negatives. thats not constructive criticism, i mean who are you trying to "construct" with ur criticisms? according to me a critic is someone who throws in positives as well as negatives. when you just spit out negatives, then u r no longer a critic and no one will even pay attention to ur negatives, and ppl like us will only oppose it.

---

already, there is a lot of people here to point out the positives of ARR.. so only i am bringing out the negative side of him.. Cover-up panna yaaravathu try pannaa, naan vanthu matter-a open pannuven.. :P

---

But you must remember there are also more negative sides with kamal and ilayaraja. 8-)

---

please see their respective threads.. we are discussing that too..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

please see their respective threads.. we are discussing that too..

---

At times, kamal's -ves are discussed in ARR section too (If I am not wrong) :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by selvakumar

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

please see their respective threads.. we are discussing that too..

---

At times, kamal's -ves are discussed in ARR section too (If I am not wrong) :D

---

in the same length as Ajith fans discuss abt Bala's -ves and IR's fans discuss abt Mani's -ves in their threads........its all natural....infact i wud call ARR fans as most subdued in showing their dissent....... :D

but i still wud like to see discussions abt ARR and his music/films only here........bcos, many ppl. satisfy their long burning ARR hatred by bashing ARR under the pretext that some ARR fans spoke negatively abt kamal......

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

in the same length as Ajith fans discuss abt Bala's -ves and IR's fans discuss abt Mani's -ves in their threads........its all natural....infact i wud call ARR fans as most subdued in showing their dissent....... :D

---

Yes Maddy. You are quite right reg the highlighted.
I disagree with the later part though :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by selvakumar

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

in the same length as Ajith fans discuss abt Bala's -ves and IR's fans discuss abt Mani's -ves in their threads........its all natural....infact i wud call ARR fans as most subdued in showing their dissent....... :D

---

Yes Maddy. You are quite right reg the highlighted.
I disagree with the later part though :)

---

yeah, u r right........2 wrongs dont make one right :D .....bashing kamal here is unneccessary and is out of context........but if someone discusses abt kamal here, they are not neccesarily ARR fans always or they do it out of ARR fanatism........the last arguement on kamal we had here had nuthing to do with ARR fanatism........but u never seem to spare a chance to police ARR fans.......i dont think if u say the truth 100 times it doesnt bcome all the more correct

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

yeah, u r right........2 wrongs dont make one right :D .....bashing kamal here is unneccessary and is out of context........but if someone discusses abt kamal here, they are not neccesarily ARR fans always or they do it out of ARR fanatism........

---

Yes. Maddy. Those two wrongs doesn't make this one right. Most of the time, kamal will be brought whether it is within the context (films) or out of context (anything not related to films). Again, everyone has the right to discuss on films since it will be their MD who is going to work with him.

Quote:

---

the last arguement on kamal we had here had nuthing to do with ARR fanatism........but u never seem to spare a moment to police ARR fans.......

---

Yes, It has nothing to do with fanatism. Only thing is that, fanatism triggered it and remained silent. I never police people. There are many 'chosen' ones here for those jobs. I just pointed out that even kamal -ves were discussed in this section without restricting them to TF section alone

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by selvakumar

Quote:

---

the last arguement on kamal we had here had nuthing to do with ARR fanatism........but u never seem to spare a moment to police ARR fans.......

---

Yes, It has nothing to do with fanatism. Only thing is that, fanatism triggered it and remained silent. I never police people. There are many 'chosen' ones here for those jobs. I just pointed out that even kamal -ves were discussed in this section without restricting them to TF section alone

---

if i remember correctly, the arguement started betn thilak and RS or someone - no way it was related to ARR fans.........pala mugam sulikkum sambavangal vaarthaigal koora pattullana, aanal, adhai marupadiyum, maupadiyum kilara vendaame :D .......also that doesent give license for ppl. to come here unneccessarily and talk crap here......... :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

if i remember correctly, the arguement started betn thilak and RS or someone - no way it was related to ARR fans.........pala mugam sulikkum sambavangal vaarthaigal koora pattullana, aanal, adhai marupadiyum, maupadiyum kilara vendaame :D

---

:o I thought I didn't brought them once again. I just said that even kamal was not spared in this section and his -ves were also analysed. When kamal's -ves can be discussed in Arr section, then why not the same can't be done for ARR in his section. Even if it a crap comment, Arr fans can post against the craps just like kamal fans once did in this section. Am I right ?

Quote:

---

.

---

Quote:

---

......also that doesent give license for ppl. to come here unneccessarily and talk crap here......... :D

---

Sure. It doesn't give license. It is just that many discuss on other areas as well

Maddy,

neenga thevai illaamal, "intha pasangala vambukku ilithu remba naal aache"-nu yosichu adikkira posts thaan athigam..

back to tenali-album,

Kamal's singing in tenali wasnt sounding great as it usually is.. i dunno why..

is it because of the way ARR mixes his songs :huh:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by selvakumar

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

if i remember correctly, the arguement started betn thilak and RS or someone - no way it was related to ARR fans.......[b]..pala mugam sulikkum sambavangal vaarthaigal koora pattullana, aanal, adhai marupadiyum, maupadiyum kilara vendaame :D

---

:o I thought I didn't brought them once again. I just said that even kamal was not spared in this section and his -ves were also analysed. When kamal's -ves can be discussed in Arr section, then why not the same can't be done for ARR in his section. Even if it a crap comment, Arr fans can post against the craps just like kamal fans once did in this section. Am I right ?

---

again, u r endorsing the 2 wrongs=1 right analogy.......just bcos some guys talked abt kamal here doesent mean, u have to take up the charge and talk crap abt ARR here......

Quote:

---

Sure. It doesn't give license. It is just that many discuss on other areas as well

---

see, u r trying to dig on that one incident again and again........keep digging :wink: :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Kamal's singing in tenali wasnt sounding great as it usually is.. i dunno why..

is it because of the way ARR mixes his songs :huh:

---

:lol: Karthik, That is because of pathetic singing by kamal. U keep trying :lol2: kettukonga makkaley, ithukku paer thaan constructive criticism

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Maddy,

neenga thevai illaamal, "intha pasangala vambukku ilithu remba naal aache"-nu yosichu adikkira posts thaan athigam..

---

DM, i very well understand how much respect u have for ARR.......i have seen ur orkut community and discussions on ARR in that..... :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

back to tenali-album,

Kamal's singing in tenali wasnt sounding great as it usually is.. i dunno why..

is it because of the way ARR mixes his songs :huh:

---

to sing in ARR's song is easier than in IR songs.......with ARR's style of recording, u can have multiple takes - like one take for each line even............

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Maddy,

neenga thevai illaamal, "intha pasangala vambukku ilithu remba naal aache"-nu yosichu adikkira posts thaan athigam..

---

DM, i very well understand how much respect u have for ARR.......i have seen ur orkut community and discussions on ARR in that..... :)

---

:notthatway: Those are constructive criticisms as per Karthik

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ramakrishna

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Maddy,

neenga thevai illaamal, "intha pasangala vambukku ilithu remba naal aache"-nu yosichu adikkira posts thaan athigam..

---

DM, i very well understand how much respect u have for ARR.......i have seen ur orkut community and discussions on ARR in that..... :)

---

:notthatway: Those are constructive criticisms as per Karthik

---

chaa avarakku ARR mela dhaan evalavu akkara :cry:

I liked "Alankatti" only on first hearings. On repeaded listenings swasame is OK type melody but others?

I would rate Tenali music is less than any kamal album composed by raja

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

again, u r endorsing the 2 wrongs=1 right analogy.......just bcos some guys talked abt kamal here doesent mean, u have to take up the charge and talk crap abt ARR here......

---

Did I ?
Discussing on Arr in Arr section > quite right. Arr fans have every right to defend that.
Discussing on kamal in Arr section > Wrong
Discussing on Arr in kamal section > Wrong
Discussing on kamal in kamal section > Right

Now, please tell me which one is right, wrong :o

Quote:

---

see, u r trying to dig on that one incident again and again........keep digging :wink: :lol:

---

I think you want to stop crap comments. That is quite right from your side. At the same time, you have posted against CRAP comments on kamal here as well. Now, everyone is not like you or me They do repeat the rights and wrongs. I wasn't referring to that 'SET'

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by selvakumar

Did I ?
Discussing on Arr in Arr section > quite right. Arr fans have every right to defend that.
Discussing on kamal in Arr section > Wrong
Discussing on Arr in kamal section > Wrong
Discussing on kamal in kamal section > Right

---

selva. let me tell u one simple thing - even though we wud have kept quiet on kamal, there wud have been ARR bashing.....

also, criticisms on ARR are like mudiya virichittu aadaraaru, paaduraaaru, thamizh drohi, IR madhiri music poda theriyaadhu - enna idhellam??? these are also wrong :wink:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by selvakumar

Did I ?
Discussing on Arr in Arr section > quite right. Arr fans have every right to defend that.
Discussing on kamal in Arr section > Wrong
Discussing on Arr in kamal section > Wrong
Discussing on kamal in kamal section > Right

---

selva. let me tell u one simple thing - even though we wud have kept quiet on kamal, there wud have been ARR bashing.....

also, criticisms on ARR are like mudiya virichittu aadaraaru, paaduraaaru, thamizh drohi, IR madhiri music poda theriyaadhu - enna idhellam??? these are also wrong :wink:

---

One more.kamal seriyaa paadaathathukku ARR thaan kaaranam etc :lol2:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tamilan

I liked "Alankatti" only on first hearings. On repeaded listenings swasame is OK type melody but others?

I would rate Tenali music is less than any kamal album composed by raja

---

:lol: i lov all the songs in this movie esp title song dono how u posted this comment.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ramakrishna

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by selvakumar

Did I ?
Discussing on Arr in Arr section > quite right. Arr fans have every right to defend that.
Discussing on kamal in Arr section > Wrong
Discussing on Arr in kamal section > Wrong
Discussing on kamal in kamal section > Right

---

selva. let me tell u one simple thing - even though we wud have kept quiet on kamal, there wud have been ARR bashing.....

also, criticisms on ARR are like mudiya virichittu aadaraaru, paaduraaaru, thamizh drohi, IR madhiri music poda theriyaadhu - enna idhellam??? these are also wrong :wink:

---

One more.kamal seriyaa paadaathathukku ARR thaan kaaranam etc :lol2:

---

:lol: DM is this what u mean by constructive criticism? no singer sounds better in ANY OTHER MD's recording than in ARRs. so if kamal sounds bad in thenali, imagine how much worse he would sound in other MDs. so now be glad that it was this good :lol:

as per me, i thot kamal's singing/ arrs recording was just right for the mood of the song. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prasana84

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tamilan

I liked "Alankatti" only on first hearings. On repeaded listenings swasame is OK type melody but others?

I would rate Tenali music is less than any kamal album composed by raja

---

:lol: i lov all the songs in this movie esp title song dono how u posted this comment.

---

It doesn't matter whether you love or not. Thats my opinion

I guess thenali had two songs sung by kamal...

yes, injiringo and alangkatti

i have never heard kamals voice so great than in aalangatti song...
"kulamkaattum vennilavaai... azhagaana nam kudumbam, kallonru erivadhaal kalangalaama..."

also in injerungo...
"senjadhellaam ninaikkakka sirikka thonudhu.."

in these places kamals voice sound really greater than his any other numbers...

but someone complains here that kamals voice sound bad in arrs mix...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SoftSword

but someone complains here that kamals voice sound bad in arrs mix...

---

avarukku Kamal-a koraichi paesinaalum paravaalla aana ARR-a mattam thattiye aaganum-ngra veri, athukku thaan puthusu puthusaa vazhi thedraaru :lol2:

What about Swades next?

ennoda ella posts-kkum inge nallaa response kidaikkuthey :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

ennoda ella posts-kkum inge nallaa response kidaikkuthey :lol:

---

pinna, neenga constructive criticiser aache :lol2:

Swades :notworthy:

Swades is :notworthy:

the songs have a nostalgic effect on the listener.

one word: soul-stirring. i would like to pinpoint one particular thing: the interludes in kaaveriya/saaveriya is just amazing. i feel like flying when i hear those.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ramakrishna

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SoftSword

but someone complains here that kamals voice sound bad in arrs mix...

---

avarukku Kamal-a koraichi paesinaalum paravaalla aana ARR-a mattam thattiye aaganum-ngra veri, athukku thaan puthusu puthusaa vazhi thedraaru :lol2:

---

:lol: ramakrishna sir,intha hub-la neenga than romba soft innu nenechen,devar magan unngallayum 'aruva' thukka vechuduvaru pola! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

ennoda ella posts-kkum inge nallaa response kidaikkuthey :lol:

---

athan unngala'thuppu thuppu innu thupparanngale'antha responce-sa sollarinngala??? :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

ennoda ella posts-kkum inge nallaa response kidaikkuthey :lol:

---

yaar enna sonnaalum response kedaikkum inga... :)
so keep posting DM

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SoftSword

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

ennoda ella posts-kkum inge nallaa response kidaikkuthey :lol:

---

yaar enna sonnaalum response kedaikkum inga... :)
so keep posting DM

---

coming to swades,

I feel that its a good album from ARR..

I like the BGM in that hydro power plant scene..

My picks from the album are
Yun Hi Chala
Dekho Na
Pal Pal
Yeh Jo Des Hai Tera
8-)

Yes, it had a very good BG score...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SoftSword

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Devar Magan

ennoda ella posts-kkum inge nallaa response kidaikkuthey :lol:

---

yaar enna sonnaalum response kedaikkum inga... :)
so keep posting DM

---

coming to swades,

I feel that its a good album from ARR..

I like the BGM in that hydro power plant scene..

---

neenga Hindi padam ellaam paappeenglaa :o