HEY FRNZ SOME TIMES I FEEL LIKE
"THENISAI THENDRAL" DEVA IS GOOD AS"ISAINGANI"ILAYARAJA
WAT DO U ALL THINK :?: :?:
Printable View
HEY FRNZ SOME TIMES I FEEL LIKE
"THENISAI THENDRAL" DEVA IS GOOD AS"ISAINGANI"ILAYARAJA
WAT DO U ALL THINK :?: :?:
NONSENSE!!!!!!!!!HOW DARE U??????????? :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:
ARE U INSANE????IR CANT BE COMPARED WITH ANY OTHR INDIAN MUSIC DIRECTOR!! HE IS PAR EXCELLENCE!!!HOW?HOW?HOW?HOW COULD U COMPARE HIM with DEVA???????tsk tsk tsk...
relax..relax...I'm a diehard fanof "maestro"Dr.IlayarajaQuote:
Originally Posted by vickyvichu
but i just ask your opinion
8) 8) 8)
JOKE OF the world
Vincent
What happened to you...
Please start such meaningless conversation....
Go and Have a Nice Cup Of Coffee :-)
Vincent,
I seriously pity you dude.
Recall the dialogue in Kaaka Kaaka by Human Rights Commission Lady..
"Atrocious!! Inhuman!! Something is wrong somewhere!".
God, please forgive Vincent. He know not that this is one of the most foolish question ever asked in Music world.
Vincent,
.. and you have told that you are "diehard fanof "maestro"Dr.Ilayaraja "....
What a disgrace to the Maestro.
Yeah.... correct vincent...
Atleast Deva comes nearer to IR in some of his compositions... :)
But ARR.. can spend his whole lifetime, but would not achieve even 10% of IRs music creativity... ;-)
Enna vincent.. correct thaana...?? :lol:
Aarambichaachu sandai inge! Ellorum odivaanga.
Appo ARR, Devaa vida mattama?
:huh:
Sudalai...
If Deva = IR
Then we never want ARR to reach there
vincent, yenna aachu ungalukku? ippa kaathu IR kittarundhu ARR and Deva pakkama povuthu. idha Deva paartha kooda tharkolai pannippar. Idukku oru votting and 4 peru amaam sollirukkanga. vekkakedu
yow Sudalai - y the hell ru bringing my Lord ARR in here!! Mind what u say abt our Lord!!
arjuna machi...
cool down..!
Ivvlo kobam koodaadhu.. :)
Btw, After maathrubootham.. ippo vera oruthar 'laadu' aayittaaraa..?? ;-) chumaa thaan paa.. serious-aa eduthukkaadha..
Come to think of it, Deva did become a competiton for IR in a big way. People always claim that ARR was the cause of IR's downfall. That is not really true.
In IR's heyday he used to do 20 to 30 films per year. Wheras ARR has been maintaining a steady average of around 5 movies per year right from the beginning. It was Deva who crashed the party by signing up more than 30 movies per year, year after year and flooding the TFM. It is unfair to say that ARR competed against IR...
It also helped that sometimes Deva's music sounded pretty close to IR's. People were already familiar with that kind of music and hence took to it easily. Deva started making inroads into IR's market. True, sometimes he blatantly lifted even current IR songs, for ex. he copied the then immensely popular "Chinna raasave chitterumbu enna..." from Walter Vetrivel in his "sendoora pandikoru jodi kili..." song for sendoorapandi(?). I am sure there are many like these, but this is one instance that immediately came to my mind.
Of course, he has the right to copy from any source in the world. That is another reason for his success.
Mind you, I am comparing Deva and IR only in terms of numbers and not in terms of quality. Of course, Deva can never match IR quality-wise, but in terms of quantity (which is a big attribute in IR's resume...) he nearly equalled him, at least for some time. And of course, he has run out of gas within a span of 10 years.
How can anyone come up with a statement like "Deva is as good as IR"? Even if it is meant just for seeking anyone's opinion. This statement was utterly shocking to me as an ardent fan of Isaignani. I don hate Deva. Some may think Deva is not good and others may even think he's good but "as good as Isaignani"? Definite "NO".
Ungalukku yaenga inthamathiri kelviyellam thondruthu? Appadiye thondrinaalum intha kelviye ketkalama? athuvum TFM thaLathile? :)
Sudalai - Ok :)
Ok.. ok. I got it.
Vincent wanted many people to come into this thread and tear Deva into pieces. Adhukku ivvalavvu illogical kelvi-yae vaendaam. Summaa... "Deva and his music machine"-nnu oru thread irundhaalae podhum.. aalaalukku vandhu thittittu povaanga. Paavam, Deva indha thread-ai paarthaa yaendaa indha thozhilukku vandhom-nnu nenaippaar.
Kamarajc, dont be jealous. Deva is Mozart.
.
.
.
.
.
(If arr is mozart, why not deva?)
:P
Appadi podunga hhhwalrus,
if ARR is asian Mozart, Mozart should be Western Deva..!
enna sollreenga..?? :)
Mozart,
Plsssss mannichidunga... i never meant that...
HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA......HILARIOUS!! !! :lol: :rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sudalai
corectu thaan !!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Sudalai
hey guyz "maestro"Dr. ilayaraja is the greatest ever MD in the world but Deva is also good as well,gave so many good songs
that all i also NEVER AGREE THAT
"THENISAI THENDRAL" IS EQUAL TO "ISAINGANI"
See, Vincent has started a interesting topic....if u look closely at the 90's saga it will always be remembered for ARR and his exploits in TN and his dominance in Hindi heartland........but it was deva who ate into IR's chances.......ppl. who could not afford IR went to deva....it was deva who damaged IR more than ARR......ARR's group was a different league and they never wanted to go back to IR.........this i just statistics but on quality, even MSV,ARR & KVM wud struggle to compete with IR so leave alone deva........
but i do take strong objection to ppl. who criticise ARR on the slightest oppurtunity provided......this is bad......see ur IR is gr8 then prove it by telling gud things abt him and not by degrading ARR.....IR is gr8 bcos of his own creations and not bcos of ARR's bad creations.......i dunt know IR fans never seem to understand this......
well said MADDY - MADDY HO HO MADDY :)
Good one... illa arujuna... maddy.. maddy.. tune.. HJ-odadhu thaana...?? ;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Arjuna
kalakki iruppaaru..
Sudalai - without Deva - supanum, kupanum - music patti therinchu iruka matanga!!Deva shuld be wrote in the annals of history!!
Even though deva gets inspired/copies - who cares - the end product is good - Priyamudan, Valli and Mugavari were Deva's best albums!!
Deva + Rajni - introduction songs were good too!!
Deva is a good MD!! and a nice human - which is more important - since many MD's except ARR lack this!!
MADDY after such a long time you have come to accept this. Iam happy for you :DQuote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
Deva is good bec he composed music like ilayaraja did for some years. Now he copies all kinds of mds vidyasagar, jassie gift. but he is not at same level as ilayaraja.
gjani deserves dredit for ruling the tc field in 1980's, 1990's
Ada ingapaarra Arjunakku endha MD nallavan endha MD kettavannu theriyum pola irukky. Arjuna neenga nallavara kettavaraQuote:
Originally Posted by Arjuna
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by njv
Deva is a good MD.... but no way near to IR.....
APPA IPPE THAN ORU NALLE RESPONSE KEDECHATHU!!Quote:
Originally Posted by svaisn
10X svaisn!
I saw another thread[by same person who started this thread] Vidyasagar is as good as ARR and this one saying Deva is as good as IR and there was comparision between ARR and IR before..It all leads to inevitable..
Vidyasagar=ARR
ARR=IR
IR=Deva
Vidyasagar = Deva
Ooops..Billions and Billions of Vidyasagar and Deva fans..I know it might upset you, but Mathematics formula just proved it..
:shock: adengappa!!! :shock:
Yaaru IsaiPsunami nnu mudivayiruchaa? Resulta sollunga.:huh:
Those guys who think on those lines have to be dismissed as those who do not have any idea on what music is all about.
The levels achieved by Isaignani can only be equated with MSV and nobody can match his musical skills and the creativity.
Some of the songs of raja like in Nenjathai killadhey are beyond imagination and they are time immemorial.
We should not even entertain such topics in future so that this portal maintains its decorum.
S.Balaji
I totally agree... IR can easily be replaced by IR. Whatever IR can do, Deva can do that, so hence I think they are equal. Take composing, arrangement, instrument, they use the same. So there you go, proves the point
I mean.. IR can be easily replaced by Deva...
Are you really serious or joking or just doing time pass ?
IR is God's gift to Tamil Music.
Deva is a copycat and has already faded.
A genius is somebody who can withstand times.
IR had sustained for 25 years in Film industry while friend Deva could not complete even 10 years. He is already a forgotten figure now