Nadigar Thilagam Sivaji Ganesan

[nilavupriyan]

good!

//shivaji is a pure actor//

yeah...he is purely an actor knly and ofcourse a wonderful actor..i m not saying that kamal is a nice actor than shivaji!

im just saying kamal takes more risk in films than shivaji by producing...kamal is more involved in cinema than shivaji!

if u take acting alone...no arguments..even kamal have confirmed it!

[S.Balaji]

dear Nilavu...

Neenga oru Kamal fan enbadhu ulagamay arindha vishayam....

Adharkaaga ..Nadigar thilagathai thaazthi ezudhavendaamay.....

You are only trying to glorify your Kamal in this thread and unknowingly you are degrading Shivaji .......

Its history that Kamal himself had acknowledged on every occasion that Nadigar thilagam is the ultimate actor that he had come across in life.....

Shivaji doesnt need any other tribute from any one....

Even the awards mean nothing to him....its what his fans think about him is paramount for him......

I wonder why SOMEONE'S FILM PRODUCTION SKILLS ARE BEING ANALYSED TO IDENTIFY WHO IS GREATER....
IF SHIVAJI DIDNT MAKE EXPERIMENTS LIKE KAMAL,

ITS A COMMERCIAL DECISION .....PROBABLY HE DIDNT WANT TO BURN HIS HARD EARNED MONEY.....

BUT IT DOESNT MEAN THAT HE IS LOWER BY ANY STANDARDS !!!

YOUR CLAIMS ARE SOMEWHAT STRANGE .....

Your definition of ROMANCE ... is invited here in this thread and not in MGR thread....

Can you pls enlighten us on your definition of ROMANCE IS ALL ABOUT ....

so that we can come up with our views on how Nadigar thilagam also did movies with romance...

HAPPY PONGAL...

[nilavupriyan]

first of all i dint degrade shivaji at all!

i accept he is best in acting!

i just mean as a overall cinema persona kamal is best!

anything wrong?

[Thirumaran]

THirumaran,
As a Sivaji Veriyan and Die-hard kamal fan,I have acknowledged that Kamal is the Best All rounder ,Where as Sivaji is the Chakkaravarthi of Acting.

Isn't it OK with you?

Absolutely. Did not i say that before? If we take only acting then shivaji is better than Kamal. In your words shivaji is the chakravarty of acting. If anyone goes back and check and never started/said anywhere that in acting department kamal is greater/ better than shivaji. I said only one thing. Kamal reached more heights than Shivaji and i explained the same in other posts that what i meant. And the manner i said was not to lower shivaji. Others thought that in a different manner. That is it.

Every Tamilian knows that in acting department alone shivaji is the king or chakravarthy. Kamal is the follower of shivaji in acting department and he is doing a good job till now.

Is that enough?

[VK Narayanan]

THirumaran,
As a Sivaji Veriyan and Die-hard kamal fan,I have acknowledged that Kamal is the Best All rounder ,Where as Sivaji is the Chakkaravarthi of Acting.

Isn't it OK with you?

Absolutely. Did not i say that before? If we take only acting then shivaji is better than Kamal. In your words shivaji is the chakravarty of acting. If anyone goes back and check and never started/said anywhere that in acting department kamal is greater/ better than shivaji. I said only one thing. Kamal reached more heights than Shivaji and i explained the same in other posts that what i meant. And the manner i said was not to lower shivaji. Others thought that in a different manner. That is it.

Every Tamilian knows that in acting department alone shivaji is the king or chakravarthy. Kamal is the follower of shivaji in acting department and he is doing a good job till now.

Is that enough?

So nice of you Thirumaran. World has become a better place to live in now. It was a wonderful discussion folks. Thoroughly enjoyed listening to all of your thoughts. Cheers!

[Shakthiprabha.]

I accept he is best in actinng!

If we take only acting then shivaji is better than Kamal.
Every Tamilian knows that in acting department alone shivaji is the king or chakravarthy. Kamal is the follower of shivaji in acting department and he is doing a good job till now.

GOOD.

AND THATS ALL, WE WANTED.

sincerely,
shivaji craze fanatic,
Shakthiprabha

[S.Balaji]

first of all i dint degrade shivaji at all!

i accept he is best in acting!

i just mean as a overall cinema persona kamal is best!

anything wrong?

Nilavu....

If you are analysing OVERALL CINEMA PERSONA....then it becomes a race between Kamal and MGR....... ultimately Kamal may win as an actor ...

[nilavupriyan]

first of all i dint degrade shivaji at all!

i accept he is best in acting!

i just mean as a overall cinema persona kamal is best!

anything wrong?

Nilavu....

If you are analysing OVERALL CINEMA PERSONA....then it becomes a race between Kamal and MGR....... ultimately Kamal may win as an actor ...

imho...no competition at all!...

[Alien]

Nilavu....

If you are analysing OVERALL CINEMA PERSONA....then it becomes a race between Kamal and MGR....... ultimately Kamal may win as an actor ...

imho...no competition at all!...

Ok,S.Balaji, now MGR vs Kamal ..... .....
I too think , no competition at all

[S.Balaji]

Nilavu and Vasanth dear....

MGR vs Kamal .....idhai MGR threadil vaithu kollalaamay please ??

Nilavu MGR threadil Nadigar thilagathai patri ezudhinaar adhanaal dhaan avarai ingay post panna chonen.....

Ultimately, Neenga rendu perum Kamalin rasigargal ! Unga thalaivarai vittu kodukkamaateeral !

Indeed Kamal , overall is the best....what I have highlighted is that Makkal thilagam also did well in other finer aspects of making a movie like Cinematography, direction, editing, music , screen play....
the only difference between Kamal and Makkal thilagam should be ACTING....

Ungal thalaivar ...how strong he is on MUSIC..... Makkal thilagam's songs are HISTORY now....even now they are being heard...
Unga thalaivar eppodhum IR follower endru ninaikiren...
Can you explain how strong Kamal is on music ? but not here it should be in MGR thread please

Bye and happy pongal