what do you hate OR like in MD ?

**coucou** · 25th July 2005, 03:26 PM

DISCUSS here fault and quality of every md

for me
ilayaraja's fault is he don't know use the western instrument in his songs
quality, he is original, use tradition instrument very well, he have own music

rahman's fault: is he take 5 or 6 month to give one album and copy the music of western
quality: good choice of singers, good mix of western and traditionnel music, quality of songs

vidyasagar fault: same style of duppanguttu songs, choice of singers in some songs, singers who don't prononced tamil very well
quality:his "dappanguttu" songs, some melodys

yuvansangar raja fault: his music look like to arr.
quality: his music look like too much arr's, foottapping songs, melodys

hj fault : he is an veritable copy cut of arr, openning of his songs with words who don't exist in tamil.
quality: good choice of singer, melodys.

**Google Adsense** · 25th July 2005 03:26 PM

**Shankar** · 25th July 2005, 03:41 PM

coucou,
what do you mean by 'western' instruments ??
IMO, when it comes to violin (viola, cello, bass), Guitar, Piano, various wind instruments (trumpet, Horns, Clarinet etc)
Raja's the best.

Pls list your 'western' instruments.

**dinesh2002** · 25th July 2005, 03:46 PM

haahahaha...athane parthen,y no one came & talk about that portion yet.....:P:P!yes shankar,he has used many western instruments,but he never succeed in giving a number which rocked the whole world,he cant even do half of what YSR is doing!im sure u agree with me rite?!

**MADDY** · 25th July 2005, 04:15 PM

coucou,

first of all,the allegations that u hve put on MDs are wrong atleast for ARR and IR....

IR has used western instruments but his recording quality was not good...so u feel he has never used western instruments

ARR has never copied from western albums....pls i'm sick and tired of this accusation....its just he has used the s/w loops from western albums....his tunes r original........infact he never uses loops as such- he reprogrammes them and then uses it.......

pls yaar, post accusations after reading our comments atleast

....we have explained these things 1000 times atleast....

**interz** · 25th July 2005, 05:11 PM

interesting thread, why did coucou not comment on rahman?? was he afraid of arr rahmans fans reactions??

**coucou** · 25th July 2005, 05:20 PM

i don't say ir don't use western music but he don't know how use in one song. i hate every songs of ir wher he use western instrument.

maddy i want to say arr inspire of western music

**coucou** · 25th July 2005, 05:21 PM

interz i haven't comment arr because i can't find fault in arr. it is most difficile.

**dinesh2002** · 25th July 2005, 05:36 PM

i can,1 of ARR's fault is he gives credit for the musican who is involved in his music,with that,many of the musicans fans claiming that that particular song the musican worked on was composed & done by that musician,like Harris jeyaraj and Ranjit barot..many hJ fans claiming that Mudhalvane in mudhalvan was done by Hj,and many bgm for ARR's movies was done by Hj...Ranjit barot too claiming he composed 2 songs in KKKK...

one more fault is that ARR used many western instruments nowdays,it was soothing to listen Sangamam when it got released...and its been a gap we listen to a pure clasical number from ARR,duncha guys think?!

**Shankar** · 25th July 2005, 05:54 PM

>>yes shankar,he has used many western instruments,but he never succeed in giving a number which rocked the whole world,he cant even do half of what YSR is doing!im sure u agree with me rite?!<<

I generally refrain from arguing with imbeciles...

**Shankar** · 25th July 2005, 06:15 PM

...and in case you know what a bass guitar is, pls listen to songs like "iLam pani thuLir vidum nEram" (from ArAdhanai) to know Raja's expertise in using them.