Critics and confusions

[Plum]

1 out of 2 posts is incorrect. Case dismissed for doctored, incorrect, unreliable evidence

[jaiganes]

Just because we show you some tiring plot points that dont seem to end their repetition shankar's movies, have we become bad critics?

Why should I not call you a bad critic? EKSI, I don't get it.

By all means - call me a bad critic. I hold a double edged sword - my opinion - I know it will hurt both ways and I have developed a thicker skin.
All i am asking is - ask critics to shut up after qualitative evaluation - not summary dismissal because u saw a "making of" video or you are a fan of some person in the movie. I ask you that because if you are overwhelmed by the affection to the product because of your "fan" leanings, then it would do you and me a world of good to accept it and move on. In a ways the whole thread is a dare - you called my VA opinion into question by saying - VA vai pugazhndhavan Endhiranai eppadi igazhalaam? - That logic itself is childish, but I thought is a good starting point in establishing a new thread - how to observe and write about a movie. though many have done it here and done it better than me, I thought it would benefit many who see movie, have opinion, but not express it in an angle.

[Nerd]

Somebody pugazhing a childish VA itself is very childish. So I am a little grown up on that aspect.

[Nerd]

are a fan of some person in the movie.

War reh waa, I was waiting for someone to bring that up. NOw I know why the Shankar hatred

[jaiganes]

Somebody pugazhing a childish VA itself is very childish. So I am a little grown up on that aspect.

Tell me grown up, what aspects of my pugazhndhifying of VA u didnt like? I dont recall going gaga over the movie or saying "only surya fossibil" to everyone. just posted an article. Adhula enna kurai kandeer kotravanE!!

[jaiganes]

are a fan of some person in the movie.

War reh waa, I was waiting for someone to bring that up. NOw I know why the Shankar hatred

Oho appadiyaa? Appo anniyan padam paathuttu sangarai pugazhndhenaa? illai sivaji padam paathuttu sangarai igazndhEnaa?
my criticism is always based on what I feel, never clouded by any other "factor" and being a fan of somebody is decidedly a factor contributing to monumental bias. Asking the windshield to be free of stains is a "wise" thing to do.

[MADDY]

neenga fublic illa.. kiritiki..

Kalavani appa: dho poraarula, arikkii(kritiki)

im not a movie critic or music critic - i really cant be one too due to my heavy preferences towards some artistes - naanum fublic dhaanungo

unakku nakkal romba jaasthia pochhu........sangar sir padam clippinge potturukkaan paaruya....critics baasayila, double entendre