-
29th September 2008, 09:07 PM
#31
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
Originally Posted by
inetk
Originally Posted by
vasanth2006
Originally Posted by
inetk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IlHgbOWj4o
Reminds anyone of anything?
It reminds me the saranam of ayirathil oruvan from iruvar....
Interesting! Let's see others' opinions too! Else, just head to
http://www.itwofs.com/ to know what I think. I don't want to influence anyone's thinking when they listen to this - that's why I don't want to post it directly.
First, I thought its not even close to be called a coincidence. On second hearing, eventhough it sounds similar I feel its a very common microtune. I guess if you play it on piano it might sound similar to Chariots of fire also (?). It is also a common melody in guitar solos I think.. I cant remember any particular song though.
In short... I think it doesnt need an entry
A black cat crossing your path signifies that the animal is going somewhere.
-
29th September 2008 09:07 PM
# ADS
Circuit advertisement
-
29th September 2008, 09:51 PM
#32
Originally Posted by
thamizhvaanan
Originally Posted by
inetk
Originally Posted by
vasanth2006
Originally Posted by
inetk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IlHgbOWj4o
Reminds anyone of anything?
It reminds me the saranam of ayirathil oruvan from iruvar....
Interesting! Let's see others' opinions too! Else, just head to
http://www.itwofs.com/ to know what I think. I don't want to influence anyone's thinking when they listen to this - that's why I don't want to post it directly.
First, I thought its not even close to be called a coincidence. On second hearing, eventhough it sounds similar I feel its a very common microtune. I guess if you play it on piano it might sound similar to Chariots of fire also (?). It is also a common melody in guitar solos I think.. I cant remember any particular song though.
In short... I think it doesnt need an entry
The tune is "just" an arohana and avarohana (so called in carnatic music, don't know how it's called in english) of four notes which is often used. I think I heard in an ad too. It is very common and I don't think it can be called a lift.
-
29th September 2008, 09:58 PM
#33
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
Originally Posted by
inetk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IlHgbOWj4o
Reminds anyone of anything?
Karthik, Yes i does look similar, especially the first four lines of Dosthu and the rhythm too. But i really don't know whether to call this a coincidence or lifted.
IMHO, Tune of dosthu song is not something very great, a simple tune hummable tune. Do you think this tune really needs inspiration. So this must be coincidence
யுவன் இசை ராஜா...
-
29th September 2008, 10:28 PM
#34
Senior Member
Regular Hubber
Originally Posted by
viraajan
Originally Posted by
inetk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IlHgbOWj4o
Reminds anyone of anything?
Karthik, Yes i does look similar, especially the first four lines of Dosthu and the rhythm too. But i really don't know whether to call this a coincidence or lifted.
IMHO, Tune of dosthu song is not something very great, a simple tune hummable tune. Do you think this tune really needs inspiration. So this must be coincidence
Super Viraajan.. sila samayam nallaa thaan blog ezhudhureenga.. adhai vida romba nallaave HJ-vai criticize panni sandhoshappadureenga..
Aanaa.. unga judgement irukke... chance-ae illa.. hereafter, if the tune is simple and hummable... let us assume that the song had no copies, not even inspirations. It is sheer coincidence. Indha yardstick-a marandhu engeyum tholaichudaadheenga... please keep it safe. I only wish that you use the same yardstick for others' songs also.
-
29th September 2008, 10:31 PM
#35
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
Originally Posted by
Kumarappa
Originally Posted by
thamizhvaanan
Originally Posted by
inetk
Originally Posted by
vasanth2006
Originally Posted by
inetk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IlHgbOWj4o
Reminds anyone of anything?
It reminds me the saranam of ayirathil oruvan from iruvar....
Interesting! Let's see others' opinions too! Else, just head to
http://www.itwofs.com/ to know what I think. I don't want to influence anyone's thinking when they listen to this - that's why I don't want to post it directly.
First, I thought its not even close to be called a coincidence. On second hearing, eventhough it sounds similar I feel its a very common microtune. I guess if you play it on piano it might sound similar to Chariots of fire also (?). It is also a common melody in guitar solos I think.. I cant remember any particular song though.
In short... I think it doesnt need an entry
The tune is "just" an arohana and avarohana (so called in carnatic music, don't know how it's called in english) of four notes which is often used. I think I heard in an ad too. It is very common and I don't think it can be called a lift.
Yes.. I agree with you eventhough I am not qualified to pass judgement on musical terms, I would assume it to be right :P
A black cat crossing your path signifies that the animal is going somewhere.
-
30th September 2008, 12:10 AM
#36
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
Super Viraajan.. sila samayam nallaa thaan blog ezhudhureenga.. adhai vida romba nallaave HJ-vai criticize panni sandhoshappadureenga..
Aanaa.. unga judgement irukke... chance-ae illa.. hereafter, if the tune is simple and hummable... let us assume that the song had no copies, not even inspirations. It is sheer coincidence. Indha yardstick-a marandhu engeyum tholaichudaadheenga... please keep it safe. I only wish that you use the same yardstick for others' songs also.
KAMARAJ
post-a ozhunga padinga...
i haven't declared that d dosthu song is original. have i?
karthik-oda opiniona avar kitta ketten. neanga yen mookka nozhaikareenga...
betw, HJ-va edhukku inga izhukkareenga, avar than padathukku padam anga inga kaiya vaikkararu. VA-la than konjam nalla potturukkaru nu sandhosha patten. but adhulaiyum mundhinam inspired nu pesikaranga. am yet to listen to george michael's track. also, where did i criticize HJ for a coincidence?
padathukku padam he is copying. but of late yuvan is doin away wit lifts. very very few of his recent compositions had lifts. so we can trust him (atleast till someone comes wit a new finding).
only his recent saroja had two inspired works. one is cheeky and the other his this dosthu.
யுவன் இசை ராஜா...
-
30th September 2008, 11:34 AM
#37
Senior Member
Diamond Hubber
Originally Posted by
vasanth2006
Originally Posted by
inetk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IlHgbOWj4o
Reminds anyone of anything?
It reminds me the saranam of ayirathil oruvan from iruvar....
u hit the nail right!!
-
2nd October 2008, 06:27 AM
#38
Senior Member
Regular Hubber
For some reason, to me, "venmaegam" from Yaaradi Nee Mohini sounds similar to "Kaadhal vaiththu" from Deepavali in the starting lines.
-
2nd October 2008, 12:52 PM
#39
Senior Member
Seasoned Hubber
Originally Posted by
inetk
Originally Posted by
vasanth2006
Originally Posted by
inetk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IlHgbOWj4o
Reminds anyone of anything?
It reminds me the saranam of ayirathil oruvan from iruvar....
Interesting! Let's see others' opinions too! Else, just head to
http://www.itwofs.com/ to know what I think. I don't want to influence anyone's thinking when they listen to this - that's why I don't want to post it directly.
Karthik , You joined the hub on 26 dec ,2004!!!!!!!
BTW , where have you mentioned about this in ur website ?
-
2nd October 2008, 04:31 PM
#40
Senior Member
Senior Hubber
Yen Ramki, naan 2004'la serakoodaadha? Or was the multiple exclamation added to denote that we joined the hub on the same day?
This one's listed in the index page now - will move it to coincidences soon.
Bookmarks