Quote Originally Posted by Sureshs65 View Post
thumburu,

Would love to have your uncompromising views on Ponnar Shankar. Hope you get to listen to it soon.

On ASK, I will beg to differ about the kuthirai song. It would have lost its nativity if SPB had sung it. The imperfection of Raja's voice adds a lot to the song and my guess is it will suit the character in the film better. We can decide on this only when the film is released
Hi Suresh, thank you for your understanding and I dont think the question of compromise or uncompromise arises here in this free forum where one can post what he or she opines about an album.As you had said in one of your posts, it is the urge to post one's opinion regarding a new music album that drives this thread . Suresh, regarding "kuthikira", I agree on the Raja's voice suiting the nativity part . I would have approved of Raja's voice in 70's or 80's when it had all the rustic youthfulness left. Now all I hear is a strained old man's voice singing for an innocent youth. You can ask me if SPB is young ,but his voice can still pull off that required youthful exuberance with nativity intact. Well, this is strictly IMO
I was wrong about the song quoted as example. It must be "maaman oru naaL". ok,I must listen to PS without delay