AR || Sakkarakatti | Kalaprabhu | Shanthanu ||

[narayanan]

I dont get something here. How could the MD be blamed for the movie not making big ? 'Duet' was a hit musical, the movie was a failure in box-office. Who will you blame?

ARR is doing music to 4 of aishwarya movies

Remember Aish's first movie

[Djpak]

I dont get something here. How could the MD be blamed for the movie not making big ? 'Duet' was a hit musical, the movie was a failure in box-office. Who will you blame?

ARR is doing music to 4 of aishwarya movies

Remember Aish's first movie

All aish's release in tamil is done by ARR

Aish debut IRUVAR (1997)
JEANS 1998
Thalam 1999
KANDUKONDAIN KANDUKONDAIN 2000

[svaisn]

When some one can compose music for Rajkiran (hero) movies.... there is nothing wrong in ARR composing songs for new comers....[/i]

appadi podu aruvala.... ......most of IR's village movies were real craps.....and they were no way exciting......infact they branded IR as a vllage composer by making him do all these crap movies.....

Exactly and now they are going to brand ARR as crap movie MD. How many ARR movies are hit, tell me about this. You yourself can do the math. I dont want ARR to do the same mistake that IR did.

Like I said, you guys just dont get it. - Enjoy.

buggle, You go my point buddy

btw kadhal not a rich girl poor boy story. more than money nativity and natural acting, unexpected climax, excellent songs and top of that media publicity that it is a true story helped Kadhal. Like Meera Jasmine said in one interview, Kadhal is the best movie that Tamil folks can come up with

Thanks for accepting that IR did mistakes.....

Sir!! even in this movie they have only told that a rich gal loves a poor guy...... they didnt mention anything else...

how do u jump into conclusions that it will be a mediocre movie??

[nilavupriyan]

A rich girl falls in love with a boy belonging to middle class family. What happens after that is the story of ‘Sakkarakatti.’

This is something tamil filmdom never experienced before. Its going to be something different. ARR is getting very exciting project now a days.

Atleast he's getting offers, and not retired (And i'm not thinking about Ilayaraja )

in last few YEARS arr have composed (after 2000)

a ah(2005)
kangalal kaidhu sei(2004)
new(2004)
enakku 20 unakku 18(2004)
boys(2003)
baba(2002)
parasuram(2003)
udaya(2003)
Kadhal Virus (2002)
Star (2001/II)
Paarthale Paravasam (2001)

these are the tamil films arr composed after 2000!

nearly all are flops....among those a ah,enaku 20 unaku 18 ,parasuram,udaya,kadhal virus,star are craps!


balachander,mani and shanker movies are accepted..but the remaining movie selection is worst!

ilayaraja's hit list after 2000

virumaandi
azhagi
ramana
pithamagan
friends

after 2000 ilayaraja had been involved in more hit films than arr and ilayaraja have involved in more decent movies than enaku 20 unaku 18,parasuram,a ah,udaya,kadhal virus,star etc...

arr compose nice music..but his film selection is not good!

[Ramakrishna]

Nilavu,
I need to agree with u that his selection of films in tamil wasn't good.
But at that time he was concentrating fully on Hindi movies and when u do that these things will happen.

[MADDY]

yes nilavu, all ARR's movies bombed after 2000......but do u know BOYS's music sales > all of IR's movies' music sales post2000......

[Djpak]

A rich girl falls in love with a boy belonging to middle class family. What happens after that is the story of ‘Sakkarakatti.’

This is something tamil filmdom never experienced before. Its going to be something different. ARR is getting very exciting project now a days.

Atleast he's getting offers, and not retired (And i'm not thinking about Ilayaraja )

in last few YEARS arr have composed (after 2000)

a ah(2005)
kangalal kaidhu sei(2004)
new(2004)
enakku 20 unakku 18(2004)
boys(2003)
baba(2002)
parasuram(2003)
udaya(2003)
Kadhal Virus (2002)
Star (2001/II)
Paarthale Paravasam (2001)

these are the tamil films arr composed after 2000!

nearly all are flops....among those a ah,enaku 20 unaku 18 ,parasuram,udaya,kadhal virus,star are craps!


balachander,mani and shanker movies are accepted..but the remaining movie selection is worst!

ilayaraja's hit list after 2000

virumaandi
azhagi
ramana
pithamagan
friends

after 2000 ilayaraja had been involved in more hit films than arr and ilayaraja have involved in more decent movies than enaku 20 unaku 18,parasuram,a ah,udaya,kadhal virus,star etc...

arr compose nice music..but his film selection is not good!

Let start with recent year for IR

Vishwa Thulasi
Mumbai Xpress
Adhu Oru Kanaa Kaalam
Oru Naal Oru Kanavu
Twinkle Twinkle Little Star

^^ OMG THATS FLOP

[baba88]

a ah(2005) - Movie Hit audio Super Hit
new (2004) - Movie and Audio Super Hit
aayitha eluthu (2004) - Mani Rathnam
kangalal kaidhu sei(2004) - Bharatiraja
enakku 20 unakku 18(2004) - Movie and Audio Hit
boys(2003) - Shankar
baba(2002) - Rajnikanth
parasuram(2003) - old movie
udaya(2003) - old movie
Kadhal Virus (2002) - ?
Star (2001/II) - ?
Paarthale Paravasam (2001) - Balachander's 100th movie

[narayanan]

Whats the point to prove with all these big list of statistics ?
~~~~~
maddy,
there are many movies during 92-99 composed Rahman that were box office failures too and even though their audio was good, they did'nt get the required publicity.
~~~~~

All aish's release in tamil is done by ARR

Yeah, so what did you mean ? I meant, even though Iruvar track was a big hit, the movie bombed box office.

BTW Thalam is a dubbing movie, would'nt count as being made for Tamil.

[rsubras]

List of crap movies for which IR scored music will be a much bigggger list (will need a oracle database to store all those data)

But imho the MD's definitely are not to be blamed for this...

one thing but u have to give it to IR, when ARR scores for a crappy film such those included in the list above, he will just compose the songs and escape, giving the BGM work to sabesh murali or pravin mani but IR sir will also do the bgm for those movies.... imagine the plight of someone who have to watch all those crap movies and give bgm for all the stupid things being done on the screen in the name of movies and definitely there had been far far more crappy movies, repeated cliches etc., in 1980's than today. Still he managed to produce some BGM gems for those kind of movies.... that patience and perseverance cant be seen in any of the current generation of MD's (and that includes our dear ARR too ) Selection of films, Musical hit based on director's musical sense.. all these terms only came in the recent past..... If IR would have said my music will be good only for the directors with "musical sense", then an entire breed of directors such as Rajkiran, Sunderrajan, Ramarajan, Kovai thambi and all those pattikaadu film directors wouldnt have been in Tamil filmdom.... (IR shud take the blame )