-
17th December 2006, 03:48 PM
#221
Senior Member
Diamond Hubber

Originally Posted by
cadburyboy
4.MUDHAL NAAL
-A foot-tapping number which takes off with a guitar riff proving HJ's skills in guitar. A nice one after Padava Padava song guitar riff from Vetri...SOME1 HAS COMPARED IT WITH ROOBAROO AND LUKKA CHUPKI GUITAR RIFF FROM RANG DE BASANTHI...HAHA!!VERY FUNNY!!WHEN I POINTED OUT NEW YORK NAGARAM AND STARING AT THE SUN BY U2 HAVE THE SAME GUITAR RIFF, PPL JUMP ON ME...WEL, TATS NOT THE MATTER...
well, leave out ARR here.......wat do u think abt this song's guitar riff??? is it similar to Roobaroo or not ??? If ARR copies then it doesent mean and justify HJ's copy......does it??
if sounding similar once or twice is ok, but not always as in the case of HJ.....ARR's NYN sounded similar to u2 number but how many songs of ARR sound similar to u2??? and compare that number with HJ's similarity to ARR's numbers, u'll get to know who ARR is and who HJ is.........
also, even if they are similar guitar riffs, why isnt that HJ does it first??? y is it always ARR does it and then after 6 months/ 1year HJ has to bring it???
i never knew that all guitar riffs are similar......i didnt find it similar to any Aerosmith's riffs......
_________
Rahman's music is the ringtone on God's mobile phone
-
17th December 2006 03:48 PM
# ADS
Circuit advertisement
-
17th December 2006, 03:50 PM
#222
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
just fnished heard all the songs....few repeats done... and overall the album is SO-SO.... i had better experience listenin to Paturi Veeran VV songs... all the songs in Unnale2 Album sounds very monotonous & jaring.... simular beats among all the songs, Hello Miss has Shakalaka Baby beats, Mudhal Naal has Rubaroo's flavour...and goodness... is there really any other MALE singers in Unnale Unnale other than Karthik??? a huge doubt :P.... JK :P neways,these r the negative parts...
the positive part is that 2 songs sounded good...Unnale Unnale & Vaigasi Nilave....i liked HJ's new attempt in composing some few diff style in 1 song...a good example Vaigasi Nilave & Hello Miss.... picturisation will help more on the songs,knowing Jeeva..... 
btw...isnt Krish is the winner for the Channel V's talent hunt show, Super Singer which had ARR & Adnan Saami as the judges ?!
-
17th December 2006, 03:55 PM
#223
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber

Originally Posted by
cadburyboy
Mudhal Naal,sounds too close to Rubaroo - RDB.....and i dun mean the guitar bit,but the pause inbetween the song,the drums that accompany the song after the pause.....hmm....
Hahaha....sum serious prob....hahahaa.....wel, rubaroo was actually inspired frm INXS-Beautiful Girl....hehehehe[/quote]
well...then jumping on ARR...lets look the matter on ur way...tell me ur opinion on HJ copying ARR's song that ARR copied from others?? !! and trust me...Mudhal Naal sounds more like Rubaroo than beautiful gal....
.....[/b]
-
17th December 2006, 04:03 PM
#224
Senior Member
Diamond Hubber

Originally Posted by
dinesh2002

Originally Posted by
cadburyboy
Mudhal Naal,sounds too close to Rubaroo - RDB.....and i dun mean the guitar bit,but the pause inbetween the song,the drums that accompany the song after the pause.....hmm....
Hahaha....sum serious prob....hahahaa.....wel, rubaroo was actually inspired frm INXS-Beautiful Girl....hehehehe
well...then jumping on ARR...lets look the matter on ur way...tell me ur opinion on HJ copying ARR's song that ARR copied from others?? !! and trust me...Mudhal Naal sounds more like Rubaroo than beautiful gal....
.....[/b][/quote]
haaha.....where does robaaroo sounds like Beautiful girl??? Cardburyman, y do have to accuse ARR when there is a finger pointed at HJ??? if ARR as done it, then its ok isnt it??? dont think only ARR fans accuse HJ here, all ppl like IR fans,MSV fans are also not happy abt HJ's copy leelaigal....
_________
Rahman's music is the ringtone on God's mobile phone
-
17th December 2006, 04:14 PM
#225
-
17th December 2006, 04:24 PM
#226
Oh my god maddy..ur comments r like teaching HJ how 2 play guitar....u cant justify it as a copy when the guitar riff is diff...its electric guitar la..(base)..when its set 2 certain scale, u might be hearing it similar...trust me...well, even strange kind of women has the same kind of riff...what can we do...dun be 2 bias on HJ...if u cant find any similarities between Aerosmith's lift the try listening Scorpion's guitar riff..make sure u take it the dirt in ur ears 1st so that u can find the similarities....
wel, tis is 2 dinesh...in the case of ARR, ul say its a loop..commercially available and so on...dont u noe that arr used the same loop as in Flight IC 408 BY State of Bengal and even in Aint talkin about dub to compose Shakalaka Baby????or simply wan hide the truth ha???dun la like this ha....so cheap of u....the loop has been effectively used by HJ for Hello Miss song...
-
17th December 2006, 04:27 PM
#227
-
17th December 2006, 04:43 PM
#228
Welll....inspiration/copying has always been there and will be there forever...no doubt in it.One has 2 get some kind of input sometime in the case of composing a song...Every1 falls into that category...There r alwiz a reason why they has 2 copy or inspire from other sources...its baseless to throw stones at hj.....
simple comparison:
18 Vayathil-kadal konden(the opening)
http://www.raaga.com/channels/tamil/movie/T0000468.html
Maramkothiye-Ah Ahh(the opening)
http://www.raaga.com/channels/tamil/movie/T0000690.html
-
17th December 2006, 04:53 PM
#229
-
17th December 2006, 05:49 PM
#230
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber

Originally Posted by
cadburyboy
for this topic....bring it here :
http://www.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?p=826918#826918
come there & see a surprise for u that im gonna post soon !
Bookmarks