COPYING - IN TAMIL FILM HISTORY

[kb]

did anyone hear sude sude from Bujjukaadu made in chennai..

yaarukumey theriyaatha beat.. lift pannirukaaru..

http://www.raaga.com/channels/telugu.../A0001293.html

[karthik_sa2]

Copied or Inspired? Listen and decide it for yourself

http://backgroundscore.blogspot.com/...-inspired.html

i don find any similarities not even to the slightest extent

[thamizhvaanan]

I was listening to Ohio by Crosby & Co., the bass guitar pattern sounded familiar. I think the riff was used as base for "Agar Main kahoon" from Lakshya (Loy is a rock music enthusiast ) Can experts clarify?

Ohio by Crosby,STills, Nash & Young

(If you are not sure what I am referring to, listen to the section past 2:00 when the vocals fade and the riff becomes more prominent)

Agar main kahoon

http://ww.smashits.com/music/hindi-m...in-Kahoon.html

TFM page'la idha post panna koodadho

[thumburu]

It is not that the ignominy of piracy has plagued MDs only after IR's era, but even yester year legends like MSV cannot be absolved of that malady. I rate the songs from "Karnan" among the top 5 best of MSV's long , illustrious career. Songs like "KangaL enge", "Maharajan ulagai " would live on for centuries to come. When I consider "Maharajan ulagai" as one the benchmark songs in "Karaharapriya " , imagine my shock and utter disappointment at my discovering it was almost a note to note copy from SVV's [ SVV is a classical music giant of an MD] "Anbinale uruvagum inba nilai" from a 1950's movie "Pasa valai" !!!

[app_engine]

Who is the MD of pAsavalai? Looks like MSV-TKR, which means this is a recycle and not a case of plagiarism. Are you sure it was SVV, thumburu?
(google gives different results, one even says G Ramanathan for pAsavalai)

[vijayr]

Paasavalai is by MSV-TKR. Read this interesting anecdote
http://www.dhool.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=4174

Also from what I remember Maharajan ulagai's opening line is so much different from anbinaale undaagum. I am not even sure that this is a recycle.

[thumburu]

The radio programme said the MD was SVV . But this song clearly inspires "Maharajan ulagai" not just because of the scale

[vijayr]

So from "note-to-note" copy it has now become "inspiration" ? Interesting

[Madevan94]

Neer aadiduvom starting (first 30 sec) is rip from Edith piaf number ..

listen

http://youtube.com/watch?v=kFRuLFR91e4

[MrIndia]

akila akila from neruku ner..





devaaaaaaaaaaa