-
27th April 2009, 01:01 PM
#101
Senior Member
Seasoned Hubber
Maddy,
Just comparing the first 5 movies isn't a useful indicator at all for someone like Surya. There is something called "showing promise." And that happened to Surya much later. The question is, does Prasanna show as much promise as Surya right now?
Of course, one can argue that Prasanna will find himself in the coming years and all that. We just have to wait to validate such claims.
Between Madhavan and Surya, I've to say I've changed my opinions quite a bit over the past couple of years. I used to rate Surya significantly higher than Madhavan, but not anymore. One aspect where I trust Surya more is that he singlehandedly makes some films watchable for me. This hasn't happened as often with Madhavan for me.
-
27th April 2009 01:01 PM
# ADS
Circuit advertisement
-
27th April 2009, 01:02 PM
#102
Originally Posted by
Ramakrishna
Originally Posted by
crajkumar_be
Your reasons have little to do with acting
More no. of hits = better acting it seems
ippa nee tertalle kalanthukkave illangriya???
-
27th April 2009, 01:05 PM
#103
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
-
27th April 2009, 01:39 PM
#104
Senior Member
Diamond Hubber
Originally Posted by
Ramakrishna
Originally Posted by
MADDY
why are we going upto Madhavan/dhanush,
oh...so u have accepted Dhanush as a good actor is it
ofcourse, its just that hes not my kind :P i would never call him a "hero" u know :P
Originally Posted by
Vivasaayi
ajith also couldnt stand a chance against prasanna with first 5 moves - so ajith is so inferior to prasanna va?
adhaan vikki, naanum solren - i wouldnt call Ajith as next kamalhassan or the most promising when there are so many talented guys.....
Originally Posted by
equanimus
Just comparing the first 5 movies isn't a useful indicator at all for someone like Surya
ofcourse, but the ascent or the talent that other guys displayed in their initial movies is much more than surya, which automatically rejects his claim for "best amongst the new" - thats my arguement.....
Originally Posted by
crajkumar_be
Maddy,
Purila. Are we comparing films or acting?
And adhu enna first 5 films?
i meant the initial spark shown by these guys - prasanna, dhanush, madhavan etc is much more than surya in initial days......when surya can grow on to become what he is now, then dont u think the others would outgrow him in the same amount of time......ada onnu rendu peraavadhu, surya-va better panna maattainga?? then how he is considered the best?
Originally Posted by
crajkumar_be
Your reasons have little to do with acting
namakku ellame "isayil thodanguthamma" :P
_________
Rahman's music is the ringtone on God's mobile phone
-
27th April 2009, 01:43 PM
#105
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
Maddy,
SRT-a vida pala batsmen would have had better scores (and hence promise) in their first 5 matches. adhellam matter illa.
Where the actors are now and what promise do they show for the future, adhaan matter
Prasanna, Suriya kooda ellam compare panra alavukku illa
-
27th April 2009, 01:52 PM
#106
Senior Member
Diamond Hubber
Originally Posted by
crajkumar_be
Where the actors are now and what promise do they show for the future, adhaan matter
indha angle-la paatha kooda, there are 4-5 guys (excluding abhay deol and vinay pathak) who come before surya for me
_________
Rahman's music is the ringtone on God's mobile phone
-
27th April 2009, 01:54 PM
#107
Moderator
Diamond Hubber
-
27th April 2009, 01:58 PM
#108
Senior Member
Diamond Hubber
Originally Posted by
Thirumaran
Good that people are again showing their vettiness by comparing with other actors
15 more minutes time.. Please fill as much before cleaning
should we post only good things about surya?? illa straight-a sollidunga - we wont waste our time in this thread then
_________
Rahman's music is the ringtone on God's mobile phone
-
27th April 2009, 02:04 PM
#109
Moderator
Diamond Hubber
Originally Posted by
MADDY
Originally Posted by
Thirumaran
Good that people are again showing their vettiness by comparing with other actors
15 more minutes time.. Please fill as much before cleaning
should we post only good things about surya?? illa straight-a sollidunga - we wont waste our time in this thread then
Never said that. And there are lot more negative comments already there. What is the point in bringing again and again all actors here.
We several times had did that. Even there was a separated thread from this same thread for comparision. Though some are interested there are some who does not want so at least in the respective threads.
If you guys want we can have a separate thread for comparision.
If there are other threads also with such comparisions do let us know.
-
27th April 2009, 02:20 PM
#110
Moderator
Diamond Hubber
Maddy,
katchi ellaam ippa namakethukku
Bookmarks