-
4th June 2009, 02:28 PM
#201
Senior Member
Seasoned Hubber

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram

Originally Posted by
equanimus
Two things:
1. I don't think Vikram dubbed for Prabhu Deva in 'minsArak kanavu.' I'm quite sure it was Prabhu Deva's voice. Venkiraja is perhaps confusing with 'kAdhalan.'
Mixed. Some parts PD some parrts Vikram
unga kooda pEsaNumnAlE dictionary vachikkaNum pOla irukkE : Vikram voice
Annai indira: PD voice
IIRC of course
Oh, indha matter theriyAdhE enakku. A good piece of trivia.
-
4th June 2009 02:28 PM
# ADS
Circuit advertisement
-
4th June 2009, 02:29 PM
#202
Moderator
Diamond Hubber

Originally Posted by
VENKIRAJA

Originally Posted by
littlemaster1982
Venki,
Pls do the honors :P
NeengaLum Surya Hater-A? There is a long list of 'sothai' and 'weak' performances from him. We can easily observe the contrast between Daniel Balaji and Surya in Kaaka Kaaka's final moments. Mayavi is a prime example of Surya's unimpressive slog. His commercial features show how pathetic he is Aaru(Songs esp. Paakadhe could have been better even with a expression-less J.Ravi) Vel(Both roles are plain

His sheshtaigal in 1000 jannal veedu). Interview-la kooda he 'tries hard'. Karthi is much better- Looks wise as well.
I'm not a Surya hater. And one of my favorite Surya performances is Mayaavi
Just that I sometimes feel he is given too much credit. Certainly a good actor 
indha chennai poNNunga ellArumE Surya fans pOla... ivaLunga avankitta ennatha kaNdAingannE therla... Everyone are crazy about him. erichalA varum. adhula pArunga, ellArOda Caller tune/ ringtone ellAmE Munbe va thaan.
Kadaisila unnoda kovatthukku kaaranam idhaana
JK :P
-
4th June 2009, 02:29 PM
#203
Moderator
Platinum Hubber

Originally Posted by
VENKIRAJA
I mean. Vikram qualifies into the grand pool of 'Versatile actors' very broadly. Surya ellAm "sellAdhu.. sellAdhu" Deposit-E pOyirum case.
Surya versatile illai enRal definition-il pizhai. Thread-ai moodiralaam.
மூவா? முதல்வா! இனியெம்மைச் சோரேலே
-
4th June 2009, 02:30 PM
#204
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram

Originally Posted by
equanimus
Two things:
1. I don't think Vikram dubbed for Prabhu Deva in 'minsArak kanavu.' I'm quite sure it was Prabhu Deva's voice. Venkiraja is perhaps confusing with 'kAdhalan.'
Mixed. Some parts PD some parrts Vikram
unga kooda pEsaNumnAlE dictionary vachikkaNum pOla irukkE : Vikram voice
Annai indira: PD voice
IIRC of course
See. The ones where he had to 'emote', he had to use dubbing: Dictionary. And, I'm confused about Annai Indira scene.. AIDS distribution sounds like Vikram... and then immediately Kaal paadhi Body paadhi... oooo seems PD. Someone clarify...
P.S: Milestones like Alaavudheen, Love birds, etc. should also be taken into account.
-
4th June 2009, 02:31 PM
#205
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber

Originally Posted by
Vivasaayi

Originally Posted by
Plum
I'd like to make a point here
Preparedness is not that bad a word as Hubbers seem to be insinuating here.
Surya slips ofcourse showing the effort- most notably in Ghajni but that shouldnt take away from versatility. versatility != spontaneity
I think we should judge Surya-Madhavan without taking into account 'natural acting' and 'spontaneity factor'.
Just saying.
adhethan.
the efforts put into versatility takes a toll on spontaneity...is also an issue.
to do a role which is not within ur horizon and also with spontaneity....is difficult.most of the actors who have maintained the spontaneity in their charecters have not been versatile.
two different dimentions.
Vikki,
Not only that, this whole always "natural", "spontaneous", "never tries" thing is a myth
-
4th June 2009, 02:31 PM
#206
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
Surya is definitely a versatile actor. There is no doubt about it.
LM, the way he dances for "megam karukkudhu"
What a ferfarmance
யுவன் இசை ராஜா...

-
4th June 2009, 02:31 PM
#207
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber

Originally Posted by
VENKIRAJA

Originally Posted by
crajkumar_be

Originally Posted by
VENKIRAJA
yArAvadhu Perazhagan Surya (The Boxer), Kaaka Kaaka (Very bad acting except a few sequences... ex: The scene where he screams with the plasters, glucose bottles), SOK (with Bhumika after return/ scenes in the rain/last fifteen mins with Jyo) kalaaichu udungapA... ivan imsai thAnga mudiyala...
Purila, enna solla vareenga?

I mean. Vikram qualifies into the grand pool of 'Versatile actors' very broadly. Surya ellAm "sellAdhu.. sellAdhu" Deposit-E pOyirum case.
Vikram... versatility ... sellavE selaadhu
ஊரு வம்ப பேசும்
அட உண்மை சொல்ல கூசும்
போடும் நூறு வேஷம்
தினம் பொய்ய
சொல்லி ஏசும்
ஏ தில்லா டாங்கு டாங்கு
அட என்னா உங்க போங்கு 
-
4th June 2009, 02:32 PM
#208
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber

Originally Posted by
littlemaster1982
I'm not a Surya hater. And one of my favorite Surya performances is Mayaavi

Just that I sometimes feel he is given too much credit. Certainly a good actor
indha chennai poNNunga ellArumE Surya fans pOla... ivaLunga avankitta ennatha kaNdAingannE therla... Everyone are crazy about him. erichalA varum. adhula pArunga, ellArOda Caller tune/ ringtone ellAmE Munbe va thaan.
Kadaisila unnoda kovatthukku kaaranam idhaana

JK :P
Lion's share. I didn't like Surya. And then I had to change it to I hate Surya.
-
4th June 2009, 02:32 PM
#209
Senior Member
Veteran Hubber
I have a strong feeling, most of us rate artists, for any given criteria, based on our individual likes n dislikes for the aritst. Then the whole discussoin would fissle out in usual way.
-
4th June 2009, 02:33 PM
#210
Moderator
Diamond Hubber

Originally Posted by
viraajan
LM, the way he dances for "megam karukkudhu"

What a ferfarmance

He brought the roof down in that scene. Sema applause theatre-la. That too in Bangalore
Bookmarks