Which is the last Bollywood film you saw ?

[kid-glove]

Ennathan naan Nov-oda hitlist-ya irundhalum, I have t o say it's equally possible to say Aamir in Surya's Pithamagan role would be puke-worthy.

1947 earth dilnawaz>>>>>>>>>> any rural surya can even conceive

Appadi onnum periya thilalangadi illa. Debatle IMO

The pinnacle moment is when he sees Nandita and Khanna copulating. There too, the stunned face (with bulged eyes) worked in terms of subtlety, and not nuance. I was waiting for some nuanced expression (think Mohanlal in Manjil Virinja Pookkal) till the end. there too, he coolly lits his beedi and doesn't provide anything to take over. Such kind of brilliance is what Aamir misses to lift him above Surya.

[kid-glove]

Rural-kaaga mattum Surya-va better-nu sollala. That's why I even included Mayaavi.

People will bring up Rangeela (and dare not "Fanaa" ) I'm sure. But it markedly differs from Surya's comic sense.

[MADDY]

the final scene, where nandita is being dragged out, aamir squats down to have a beedi seri vidunga, surya is great.....

the day is not far when people here wud be arguing how sam anderson was more meticulous than Aamir in yaarukku yaro.......i dont even want to be in this planet of thinking

[kid-glove]

the final scene, where nandita is being dragged out, aamir squats down to have a beedi

till the end. there too, he coolly lits his beedi and doesn't provide anything to take over.

Bringing Sam Anderson to this debate?! Again Maddy, you're taking it a bit far. And I thought I was a Parminder in my weekend conferences with friends.

I say this unabashed hyperboles would one day result in calling Ranbir kapoor as the next NT.

[MADDY]

how can someone miss the fury, pressue of racing heart beats in those eyes......

sorry KG, i dont agree to ur evaluation of aamir at all ...im ready to accept my ignorance on amitabh but aamir is exclusively my generation and my territory and someone i have watched all my life.......and i have watched surya too - lets agree to disagree

[kid-glove]

I pretty much nailed parts which one would think of 'masterclass acting' when it's 'sheer competence' on part of an actor. Of course, actor vs actor comparison will always result in polarizing divergence.

[MADDY]

I pretty much nailed parts which one would think of 'masterclass acting' when it's 'sheer competence' on part of an actor.

thats what u think

[kid-glove]

miss the fury, pressue of racing heart beats in those eyes......

Oh! I was noticing the extra kajal and cared for the bulged eyes. I hear it's a cause of deformation, to not blink your eyes for lengthy periods.

[kid-glove]

I pretty much nailed parts which one would think of 'masterclass acting' when it's 'sheer competence' on part of an actor.

thats what u think

I don't disagree. So, let's stop picking on Surya every time an Aamir film releases, shall we?

And I'm not even a Surya fan. I think Madhavan is comfortably better.

[MADDY]

im pretty clear on aamir's skills - he is a competent actor is all i'm trying to say but his oeuvre is much bigger than that of Surya, who hasnt shown initial brilliance like Abhay too........kamal, mohanlal are way above aamir and i can take these to whip almost all actors in india - thats not a correct evaluation