Which is the last Bollywood film you saw ?

[MADDY]

I pretty much nailed parts which one would think of 'masterclass acting' when it's 'sheer competence' on part of an actor.

thats what u think

I don't disagree. So, let's stop picking on Surya every time an Aamir film releases, shall we?

that was Ajay - i would surely tell him.....

kamal in 10A: oor vaaya mooda mudiyaadhu .....

i dont have any interest in talking abt surya seriously

[kid-glove]

im pretty clear on aamir's skills - he is a competent actor is all i'm trying to say but his oeuvre is much bigger than that of Surya, who hasnt shown initial brilliance like Abhay too........kamal, mohanlal are way above aamir and i can take these to whip almost all actors in india - thats not a correct evaluation

My point being that Aamir doesn't come close to whipping other competent and reasonably talented actors. So the purported air of superiority in 'talent' and in 'emoting' doesn't exist or is only minimal, especially when compared to Surya, Abhay or what have you.

I use N'shah as a yardstick for other Indhi actors. I think I shouldn't, it's just too unfair.

[MADDY]

Oh! I was noticing the extra kajal and cared for the bulged eyes

[MADDY]

My point being that Aamir doesn't come close to whipping other competent and reasonably talented actors. So the purported air of superiority in 'talent' and in 'emoting' doesn't exist or is only minimal, especially when compared to Surya, Abhay or what have you.

KG, i have seen no great samples of surya other than pithamagan, mayavi to even put him in "competent" league.......the 54 degree face turn in Nandha to depict "concentration" is .....

ask him to do the scene where abhay ditches mahi in Devd - appram paakkalam......

[kid-glove]

Do not backtrack Maddy, few pages back, you conceded aamir and surya are at same level, admittedly the level being lesser than that of Abhay.

[kid-glove]

Abhay deol >>>>>>>> Surya, Aamir

[kid-glove]

Users browsing this forum: equanimus

Another Aamir fan. Bring it on, man.

[equanimus]

Oh, but very much a Surya fan as well!

And, Maddy, looking forward to Raktha Charithra? Please don't tell us you expect Vivek Oberoi to have Surya for lunch in that one!

[MADDY]

Abhay deol >>>>>>>> Surya, Aamir

read like Level3>>>>L1,L2

And, Maddy, looking forward to Raktha Charithra?

yes, expecting a indianised kill-bill (since ramu has promised 2 episodes)......

Please don't tell us you expect Vivek Oberoi to have Surya for lunch in that one!

when someone says aamir is not great its a brilliant observation, when someone says surya is not good enuf he becomes a ridiculous guy

[MADDY]

Users browsing this forum: equanimus

Another Aamir fan. Bring it on, man.

then im a yuvan shankar raja fan