Favorite Scenes/Songs from THALAIVAR Rajini films #3

[ajithfederer]

தண்ட பசங்க!. குரு சிஷ்யன் நீட்ஸ் அட்லீஸ்ட் எ பிபுட்டி (50)!!

As you said there is no dearth of funny scenes in GS. Agreed the film is a masala but whats the big deal. It made you and me and most of us laugh and it still works. The film has a good supporting cast in the form of Prabhu, Vinu, Radharavi, Cho and Manorama. Enna irundha than ivanga othupaanga nnu puriala. And i agree with you Murattu Kaalai is no comparison to GS. GS is funny-fantastic.

40/100 for Guru Sishyan is unpardonable. Vikatan is extremely inconsistent. A much worse film, murattukkaalai gets more than this and I don't even want to talk about the *gems* these days which got around 40.

Even in the 2nd half there was no dearth of funny scenes. Only the last 20 mins or so is ordinary. Guru Sishyan should have got around 47.

[ajithfederer]

Pathinaru Vayadhinile got 63 and I posted that web-link in KH thread in this section. Andha padathukkae 63 than.

I dont think vikatan will give more than 45 for any masala movie.

But, let me contradict my own statement kalyaanaraman earned more than 55 or 60, I am not sure. Dont tell me kalyaanaraaman is not a masala movie! Bcos it is Kh who was rated highly those days no matter what movie he did. But for the past 10 years or so, Kh is in their bad book. Beats me!

[tamizharasan]

Pathinaru Vayadhinile got 63 and I posted that web-link in KH thread in this section. Andha padathukkae 63 than.

I dont think vikatan will give more than 45 for any masala movie.

But, let me contradict my own statement kalyaanaraman earned more than 55 or 60, I am not sure. Dont tell me kalyaanaraaman is not a masala movie! Bcos it is Kh who was rated highly those days no matter what movie he did. But for the past 10 years or so, Kh is in their bad book. Beats me!

AF
As a matter of fact 16 vayathinilae at 62.5 marks is highest ever by vikatan. Vikatan has its own standard for rating. IMO other kamal haasan films such as nayagan, mahanadhi and hey ram deserved more marks than 16 vayathinilae got only 60 each if that is the case.

[app_engine]

IMO other kamal haasan films such as nayagan, mahanadhi and hey ram deserved more marks than 16 vayathinilae

Strongly disagree!

16v aLavukku maRRathula either orinigalityO or nativityO irukkAdhu! You can say technically a little bit week but no other KH film has touched the heart of majority in TN. (I'm from the group that unless a film satifies majority, it could max be called good but never great. Disclaimer - the corollary is NOT TRUE!

mahAnadhi / HR were commercially far far below 16v and nAyakan too didn't have that nook and corner reach! TIME fellow doesn't know anything about TN -why, they didn't know much about even India till a few years back - and so his certificate doesn't mean much in this comparative analysis)

[Vivasaayi]

IMO other kamal haasan films such as nayagan, mahanadhi and hey ram deserved more marks than 16 vayathinilae

Strongly disagree!

16v aLavukku maRRathula either orinigalityO or nativityO irukkAdhu! You can say technically a little bit week but no other KH film has touched the heart of majority in TN. (I'm from the group that unless a film satifies majority, it could max be called good but never great. Disclaimer - the corollary is NOT TRUE!

what originality/nativity was missed in mahanadhi?

nativityna village movies mattum than nativitiya?

Standing the test of time is one important factor for a movie to be called as a GREAT movie - I dont think 16 V stands above moives like Mahanadhi in that aspect..even today - "amma naan pass ayiyen"..that veterenary doctor .. "climax barathiraja voice" looks funny...which is not the case with Mahanadhi/thevar magan/mmkr types(later part of kamal career)

[thamiz]

IMO other kamal haasan films such as nayagan, mahanadhi and hey ram deserved more marks than 16 vayathinilae

Strongly disagree!

16v aLavukku maRRathula either orinigalityO or nativityO irukkAdhu! You can say technically a little bit week but no other KH film has touched the heart of majority in TN. (I'm from the group that unless a film satifies majority, it could max be called good but never great. Disclaimer - the corollary is NOT TRUE!

mahAnadhi / HR were commercially far far below 16v and nAyakan too didn't have that nook and corner reach! TIME fellow doesn't know anything about TN -why, they didn't know much about even India till a few years back - and so his certificate doesn't mean much in this comparative analysis)

Yes, 16 vayathinile deserves to be the topper of all time. I am not sure TA talks from his heart.

[Vivasaayi]

Yes, 16 vayathinile deserves to be the topper of all time. I am not sure TA talks from his heart.

as u always do eh?

[thamiz]

IMO other kamal haasan films such as nayagan, mahanadhi and hey ram deserved more marks than 16 vayathinilae got only 60 each if that is the case.

IYO, all the three other you mentioned deserve how many marks? And which one is top-rated among the three? Or they all deserve the same marks but higher than 62.5?

Feel free to give your marks!

[PARAMASHIVAN]

what is Vikatan's rating for basha ?

[PARAMASHIVAN]

I had to admit Vinu was hilarious in GS