Khan Saheb Kamal Haasan's Jamaat/Jeba Koottam/Devasthaanam - Part 8

[sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar]

They both were like Oil & Water, from beggining itself. Before Indian also, Kamal was voicing strongly in support of IR, from the time Gentleman made ARR Popular. (Yes, roja & puthiyamugam only brought fans to ARR, its only Gentleman which brought producers in quee)

It shud be mostly that ARR composing for Indian and Thenaali wud be mostly director's choice, than kamal's. Like Harris composong for VV.

[ajaybaskar]

Yeah. True. But of late the situation has changed slightly I believe. Still Kamal is an IR fanatic but no hatred towards ARR like before.

[ajaybaskar]

And KH was supposed to be the director of Marmayogi/Thalaivan Irukkiraan, right?

[sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar]

Yes, situation is much better now. But same time, i guess there was nothing hatred against ARR, instead, too much IR support. (which most of us IR fans feel deserving)

[Arvind Srinivasan]

And KH was supposed to be the director of Marmayogi/Thalaivan Irukkiraan, right?

Yes. Which is why I am still hopeful that the collaboration will take place...

[Siv.S]

AFAIK, the difference of opinion regarding 'Indian' song was because the choice of singer for 'Pachaikkiligal'. Shankar and KH wanted KH to sing that number while ARR wanted KJY.

With due respect to Singer Kamal

chinna chinna anbil dhaane jeevan innum irukkuu
..penne narai ezhudhum suya saridham
....adhil anbe aanandham aanandham ....

All these lines Only KJY fossible

[venkkiram]

Sakala,

AFAIK, the difference of opinion regarding 'Indian' song was because the choice of singer for 'Pachaikkiligal'. Shankar and KH wanted KH to sing that number while ARR wanted KJY. That caused the rift was what I was told. There was a discussion in ARRYG reg this long back.

Any big hero has access to the film's songs and why should Kamal go and ask ARR to play the songs?

படத்தின் பாடல்கள் வெளிவந்த நேரத்தில் கல்லூரி விடுதியில் இப்படியும் ஒரு கருத்து சென்றது "கமல் படத்தில் கமல் குரலில் ஒரு பாடல் கூட இல்லை.. டூயட் "டெலிபோன் மணி போல" பாடல் கூட ஹரிக்கு சென்றிருக்கிறது. வாவ்.. நிச்சயம் ரஹ்மான் வேறுபட்டவர்தான்"

[KlamRoyA]

It shud be mostly that ARR composing for Indian and Thenaali wud be mostly director's choice, than kamal's. Like Harris composong for VV.

Indian is ok.. its shankar choice.. bt Tenali, i think it might be kamal's choice than KSR..
Otherwise KSR would think ARR would be suit for biggies...
KSR joined wit ARR in which Rajini,Kamal & Ajith was star..
He dint even think of ARR musical for Sarathkumar movie..
KSR nd Sarathkumar worked together almost above 10 films..

And also, during the release of Tenali, People dint lik the album 'Tenali' in first listen .. They felt sumthing missing in it..
When ARR is composing for a maas-hero project, he is restricted to sum limit for composing, IMO...
so he is nt able to delivering gud songs in some time..
Same case happeded for 'Padayappa'.. People dint lik 'Padayappa' album in first listen...

[Srimannarayanan]

They both were like Oil & Water, from beggining itself. Before Indian also, Kamal was voicing strongly in support of IR, from the time Gentleman made ARR Popular. (Yes, roja & puthiyamugam only brought fans to ARR, its only Gentleman which brought producers in quee)

It shud be mostly that ARR composing for Indian and Thenaali wud be mostly director's choice, than kamal's. Like Harris composong for VV.

If ARR did the music for Viswaroobam, this film would have been more popular than now. Rahman would have done wonders for these kind of movie.

i dont know when this combination will happen.

[KlamRoyA]

If ARR did the music for Viswaroobam, this film would have been more popular than now. Rahman would have done wonders for these kind of movie.

+1... Same applied for Dasavatharam..BGM la pinni iruppaaru...