Khan Saheb Kamal Haasan's Jamaat/Jeba Koottam/Devasthaanam - Part 8

[Bala (Karthik)]

app_engine
I've heard from a couple of people that SB's contribution was minimal. Samosa saapidum level (maybe an exaggeration but that was the drift). Obviously, you don't have to buy that. However, the product itself should give you a good indication, right? Kamal's signature as compared with SB's other ventures before and after. Plus, Kamal "crediting" SB doesn't change much in this argument one way or another, does it? What does "credit" here mean? And would you actually expect Kamal not to credit the director here ? Above all, you've obviously heard the Guna tape (may be staged, still...) and the famous "adhu, oru karuthu".

BTW, where does the writing vs directing debate between KG/PR stand now?

[Bala (Karthik)]

Sahala
Mikka nandri for the updated on the Raaja conneksan program, especially for the Marudh video. Will check out the video later. Unga karuthu on this?

[P_R]

BTW, where does the writing vs directing debate between KG/PR stand now?

whoy yA?

My definition of 'all encompassing writing' is theoretical and does not exist in the real world-nu mudivu aagi samaadhaanamA pOyi, aNNan thambiyA vaazhndhukittu irukkOm.

Anyway, question does not apply to Kamal, as he actively directs and creates the cinematic moments.

As you said - title card means nothing. Judge by comparative statics - keep everything else the same in that group and remu Kamal. Most useful yardstick.

[Bala (Karthik)]

Sahala
Mikka nandri for the updated on the Raaja conneksan program, especially for the Marudh video. Will check out the video later. Unga karuthu on this?

thank you Kamesh.

marudhanayagam song was great.. sounds like a siddhar type song Raja sir composed earlier like

Singara seemaiyile (Marudhu Pandi)
Kadha kelu (Karimettu karuvayan)
kadha kelu (Michal madhana kamarajan)
Appanendrum (Guna)
etc etc..

Sidhar song from Raaja = Sure Win

[Bala (Karthik)]

whoy yA?
My definition of 'all encompassing writing' is theoretical and does not exist in the real world-nu mudivu aagi samaadhaanamA pOyi, aNNan thambiyA vaazhndhukittu irukkOm.

Inga discuss pannadhungala, illa twitter liya? Sramam illenna link edacham kudukka mudiyumaannu paarunga

[SoftSword]

panakkaran - maratthavechavan song sidhar vagaila seradha?

[Bala (Karthik)]

panakkaran - maratthavechavan song sidhar vagaila seradha?

Actually enakkum indha kostin irukku, whats the actual definition of sithar songs. "Pichai Paathiram" of this type? Romba idhuva sithar songs statement adichutten. "Maratha vechavan" aligns with my vision/sound of sidhar songs and is exactly the kind i'm talking about

[P_R]

Inga discuss pannadhungala, illa twitter liya? Sramam illenna link edacham kudukka mudiyumaannu paarunga

I think it was with equar and k_g somewhere here only. thEdippArkkuREn.

Even though it is settled, every now and then, I make it a point to shout 'writing is first because it happens first' in their general direction and disappear.

[SoftSword]

flausafical... shoulder'la thappattai vechu thattikittae olagatthula pOdra ovvoru noball'kum commentry kudukradhu...

[P_R]

sidhdhar songs-na rhythm vONAvA?
General philosophy, mood ellAm pArththA ekkachekkam irukkumE... thaayuNdu thandhai uNdu petRor illE etc.