Neethane En Ponvasantham | Yeto Vellipoyindhi Manasu | Assi Nabbe Poorey Sau

[venkkiram]

Come on! We have come across and digested well the diction of Latha, Asha! இதுவும் கடந்து போகும்! பழக பழக சரியாயிடும். தமிழின் பல்வேறு வட்டார மொழி வடிவங்களின் ஒலிகளில் ஒன்றாக நெனச்சிகிட்டு போக வேண்டியதுதான்.

[V_S]

venkki sir,
Ippidi compromise panni panni thaan ippo namma music, especially singing enga vanthu nikkuthu paarunga. If it was not that glaring enough, atleast we can ignore as you say, but if it is right on the face, I can only ignore the song. That too if the first word (in an ever beautiful composition) is itself wrong, that too replacing a beautiful word ஒளி with ஒழி, and another beautiful word like விளக்கானேன் spelled as விழக்கானேன், then definitely I cannot take it more. These are just few examples, many more spoiler like that definitely kills the song. The most surprising thing about Shela Binde is she gets the most difficult word 'ழ' right, but every time at the wrong place.

[Sureshs65]

Heard from some folks that the Raja duet is supposed to be very good. Let us wait and see what Bela does. Anyway, the tracklist is in keeping in touch with the pheelings of the 'youth', who want new voices and bad pronunciation As venki says, we have to get used to it.

[venkkiram]

venkki sir,
Ippidi compromise panni panni thaan ippo namma music, especially singing enga vanthu nikkuthu paarunga. If it was not that glaring enough, atleast we can ignore as you say, but if it is right on the face, I can only ignore the song. That too if the first word (in an ever beautiful composition) is itself wrong, that too replacing a beautiful word ஒளி with ஒழி, and another beautiful word like விளக்கானேன் spelled as விழக்கானேன், then definitely I cannot take it more. These are just few examples, many more spoiler like that definitely kills the song. The most surprising thing about Shela Binde is she gets the most difficult word 'ழ' right, but every time at the wrong place.

Fully agree with you V_S Sir. But at the same time, please don't blame only the singers for their diction murder. The sanctioning authorities ( Music Director and Director of the movie) takes 50% of the blame. Blame the song making process which allows that issues come out from recording theater. When IR saying he asked a whole choir team to vacate due to their bad performance in London and had a replacement, why not firing a singer for poor diction? This always baffles me.

[Sureshs65]

V_S,

That song is just too much. Poor girls goes la for zha and zha for la and total konfees only. For that song atleast I would say Raja has to take some part of the blame. Or atleast knowing what the lyrics were, he should have given it to someone like Reeta. My personal feeling is that Raja uses Bela more as Shreya's replacement. That is what Aakarsh was also saying on twitter.

Anyway, the list looks promising. And inspite of the fact that I may be lynched, let me confess that I had no problems at all with Yuvan in 'Saindhu Saindhu'. Maybe I am 'still a young yaar' in my heart

[Plum]

booze ammAyi is Rita no? nAn kooda EdhO Anglo Indiannu nenaichEn. pArthA, SuchaRitavAm. Comments invited from Bala(Karthik)

[V_S]

For that song atleast I would say Raja has to take some part of the blame

I totally agree. My main frustration is I am skipping that wonderful song just because of her. Too terrified to go into that song.

[Plum]

Suresh - yes I also felt that Poor Man's Shreya thingy with Bela Shinde. Voice is not bad actually. Current generationla


Shreya
...
...
...
Daylight
...
...
...
...
Manjari (She is very, very, very good - aced kAiyetha kombathu on all aspects and quite a few malayalam songs including Oru CHiri Kandal highlighted by V_S in the other thread. Liked her naan thedum in Raja concert too)
Mahathi, Bela Shinde etc

Mahathi making debut with Enna maRandhAlum was very promising but seems to have lost her way after making it to the Jayaraj stable with aiyayyo pudichirukku.

(Althiough to be fair, buvvAvukku Jayaraj stable is a good place comparitively to be)

[San_K]

I think we should blame on IR too for not watching these mistakes. As said by IR, Once kamal sung பன்னீர் புஷ்பங்ஙளே instead of பன்னீர் புஷ்பங்களே and later only IR discovered. Empa asistundugala neengalavathu (neengathaan) paarkkanum idhellamm. See how Shreya Ghoshal is singing with good pronountiation, that is called dedication

[San_K]

booze ammAyi is Rita no? nAn kooda EdhO Anglo Indiannu nenaichEn. pArthA, SuchaRitavAm. Comments invited from Bala(Karthik)

I think this is another name of Bela