Annamalai - Annamalai
Aval Appadithan - Thyagu
Batsha - Manick Batsha
Guru Sishyan - Guru
Johnny - Vidyasagar/Johnny
Mullum Malarum - Kaali
Netrikkan - Chakravarthy
Thalapathy - Surya
Thambikku entha ooru - Balu
Thillu Mullu - AAK Indhiran/Chandhiran
Annamalai vs Padayappa.
Watched over the weekend. Annamalai on TV. And Padaiyappa on disc, as wife never finished watching it.
Theme the films share: fall of fortune, then the rise.
Themes they don't share:
Annamala - bromance, bovine love
Padaiyappa - sexism, and insecurity (always have 6-8 guys around you)
Music:
Annamalai - Okay, can't listen to most of the songs. Oru Pen Pura still nice. Never liked the Bond influenced theme.
Padaiyappa: Winner, always listenable. Moricone incfluenced theme that probably answers the question as to why many Rajini fans are also Eastwood fans. My nit-pick= no proper score for action scenes, unlike Muthu's full blast.
Direction:
Annamalai - Focused, probably the beginning of too many shots of hero walking craze.
Padaiyappa: Showy, camera zooming over the top, sideways, annoying as heck.
Comedy:
Annamalai: Snake scene still nice, "Kadavule kadavule" not funny anymore. As usual, pre-Vetri Nitchayam Rajini is hillarious.
Padaiyappa: Boring. Even Senthil not effective
Co-stars:
Annamalai - Very good, especially Radha Ravi
Padaiayppa: Ramya Krishnan still annoying as heck. The others so and so. Not enough NT/Rajini dynamics.
Dialogues:
Annamalai: Wonderful, especially the kanakku dialogues by Rajini.
Padaiyappa: as mentioned, pure sexism. En vazhi tani vazhi sound stupid. the nalla vazhthatha saritiriam illa is factually wrong. What if you turn it around?
Main character:
Annamalai: Lovable, you are with him when he falls and rises.
Padaiyappa: Sexist paranoid with ego as big as the very Himalaya the actor goes to.
Rajini's performance
Annamalai: One of the last great performances of his.
Padaiyappa: Lazy.
Annamalai >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Padaiyappa. Thanks god for Baba.
" நல்ல படம் , சுமாரான படம் என்பதையெல்லாம் தாண்டியவர் நடிகர் திலகம் . சிவாஜி படம் தோற்கலாம் ..சிவாஜி தோற்பதில்லை." - Joe Milton.
In padayappa, when lakshmi says "poi en marumagala kootittu vaa" and then rajni walks in to soundarya, the BGM was awesome. I think the same BGM repeated in some other scenes also. But in this scene, it was mindblowing.
Music is a great plus point in Padaiyappa, but sila edattula konjam muted-A irukkum. And lack of it during action scenes. In terms of ARR/RK collaboration Muthu trumps Padaiyappa just on the background score alone.
" நல்ல படம் , சுமாரான படம் என்பதையெல்லாம் தாண்டியவர் நடிகர் திலகம் . சிவாஜி படம் தோற்கலாம் ..சிவாஜி தோற்பதில்லை." - Joe Milton.
Om Namaste astu Bhagavan Vishveshvaraya Mahadevaya Triambakaya Tripurantakaya Trikalagni kalaya kalagnirudraya Neelakanthaya Mrutyunjayaya Sarveshvaraya Sadashivaya Shriman Mahadevaya Namah Om Namah Shivaye Om Om Namah Shivaye Om Om Namah Shivaye
Annamalaiya Padaiyappavannu ketta of course most of us will say Annamalai without any hesitation... But never knew why, my wife likes Padaiyappa very much.. She is not a Rajini fan though.
Come back strong.. Come back soon..
ramya kissnan character remba pudichirukkum... edhukkum konjam jaakradhayaa irunga..
Sach is Life..
Bookmarks