Tamil Cinema Box Office

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bill4u

Cedy, dont remember what I posted. Thuppakki downgraded because of what ? Kanchana2 and I ? For someone to prove otherwise, we need an exhaustive list from several sources to prove our claim! Just one or two links may not suffice. When I had to prove VR's box office, I posted about 7-8 links with numbers varying from 220-245 crs .. Its not straight forward if two movies are close to each other.

---

Boss, Then Thuppaki collection was mentioned as 180cr but now its mentioned as 125cr. same link. We are saying that wikipedia can be edited with whatever references suit your needs.

Thats what thread starter has also done. He posted the list which fulfils his wish. So Cedy posted a list for us.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bill4u

Cedy, dont remember what I posted. Thuppakki downgraded because of what ? Kanchana2 and I ? For someone to prove otherwise, we need an exhaustive list from several sources to prove our claim! Just one or two links may not suffice. When I had to prove VR's box office, I posted about 7-8 links with numbers varying from 220-245 crs .. Its not straight forward if two movies are close to each other.

---

Billu Ji,

Here is a link to your post

http://www.mayyam.com/talk/showthrea...34#post1205534

The same wiki link.

How can Thuppakki downgrade from 187 crore in the same link you provided and now to 125 crore in the same link after a few months?

The link has been edited and references have been considered on convenience.

Lot's of media report a lot of numbers. For some movies, the highest figure and for some movies, the lowest figure is considered in that wiki page.

Convenience based table and purely based on the whim's and fancies of the individual who maintains the page.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VinodKumar's

Mass will come in the list when it completes it run. I have heard all three versions (Tamil, Telugu and English) are running well.

---

:shock: Anglo Saxons will watch this ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dammy R

As someone said earlier, anyone with an account can make a list to suit their needs in Wikipedia these days.

Having said that, here is another list which is directly from IMDb which is mostly used by all movie lovers to check for movie ratings etc. Again, I am not saying that this is also 100% genuine or to prove anything but just wanted to share another perspective. You will find many such examples all over the internet. Rentrak was being used to track overseas collections so that list am sure is genuine and has been shared in the previous box office thread. It is only the TN collections which no one knows the truth about. Few websites do track box office numbers but again, they can always be questioned depending on what side you are on.

Top Grossing Tamil Movies of all time

No. Movie Name
1 Enthiran
2 Ai
3 Kaththi
4 Thuppaki
5 Vishwaroopam
6 Lingaa
7 Singam 2
8 Sivaji
9 Aarambam
10 Kanchana 2

Source : IMDb
Link : http://www.imdb.com/list/ls050231721/

---

We don't have the luxury to post this in the first page of the thread, don't we?

Wiki is now the toast of the town :)

English version of Masss? Idhu eppo?

Dammy ..

couple of things. The site you quoted has no other references other than their own making their case a little weak. Just check the references and links provided by wiki from independent sources ...

Moreover no offense but Kaththi and Thuppakki did not gross more than VR which was in excess of 220c.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PARAMASHIVAN

:shock: Anglo Saxons will watch this ?

---

No report on that dude.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ajaybaskar

English version of Masss? Idhu eppo?

---

http://www.mayyam.com/talk/showthrea...=1#post1231866

Ok guys understand. Need some time to dig up Thuppakki details ... 180 to 120 is not really that accurate :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bill4u

Ok guys understand. Need some time to dig up Thuppakki details ... 180 to 120 is not really that accurate :)

---

Eros International announced the release of financial results for the quarter ending 31st December, 2012. As per the announcement made by Eros, Thuppakki made a total box office collection of Rs. 180 crore (domestic) to become the fourth film to join the 100 crore club in Tamil films.

http://content.icicidirect.com/maili...ntl_Q3FY13.pdf

Certainly a better source than wikipedia or fanboy owned sites

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bill4u

Dammy ..

couple of things. The site you quoted has no other references other than their own making their case a little weak. Just check the references and links provided by wiki from independent sources ...

Moreover no offense but Kaththi and Thuppakki did not gross more than VR which was in excess of 220c.

---

Bill4u... They do reference "indianmoviestats.com" in those ratings and rankings. Not arguing here but even the links provided in Wikipedia are independent sources and we don't know where they get their information from.
This is an endless discussion because there is no transparency as far as box office numbers are considered for Tamil movies.. within India.

Personally, I think the best way to judge or gauge is how a particular star movie is treated by trade during his next release...i.e. area wise distribution rights, TV rights, or any other pre-release business factors. I mean the speed at which a movie business gets done prior to release and not the amounts paid etc..cos that again is questionable.