The Golden Era of Dr.IR and Dr.SPB

[SoftSword]

#348 வானம் தொட்டுப்போன
(தேவர் மகன், 1992 )

Another SPB song from the same movie that I've heard only a few times - mostly during bus travels. Unlike the previous song that I've heard a few times on radio, I don't remember hearing this number ever otherwise. Sounds nice, with SPB throwing in appropriate emotions (there are actually two version on thiraippAdal - both having the same melody but different orchestration / tempo etc and possibly for two different situations in the movie).

indha song'ku unga total reactionae ivlodhaanaa???

[PARAMASHIVAN]

P.S: Fcukin autotext

Humble request No swearing pls

[PARAMASHIVAN]

Faramu - I suffort you in the anti-mano crusade. In return, please post this as it is : "my (faramu's) vote is for saamikitta"

Ok App anna

My vote is for Saami kitta

[V_S]

Faramu - I suffort you in the anti-mano crusade. In return, please post this as it is : "my (faramu's) vote is for saamikitta"

neenga election'layE nikkalaam.

[jaiganes]

புடிச்ச முயலுக்கு மூணே காலுன்னு நிக்கிறிங்க. இருந்தாலும் கருத்தை வைக்கிறேன். நிறைய இருக்கிறது. மனோ பாடிய தேன்மொழி எந்தன் தேன்மொழி சிறப்பான பாடல். உங்க தர்க்கத்தில் பார்த்தால் உன்னி மேனன், மது பாலகிருஷ்ணன் போன்ற பாடகர்கள் யேசுதாசின் நகல் என சொல்லிவிடலாம். ஆனால் அப்படியல்ல. மனோவிற்கென்று ஒரு குரல் இருக்கிறது. அது பாலுவின் சாயலில், குரல் அலையில் ஒத்தது போல இருப்பதால் பாலு போலவே மனோ பாட விரும்புகிறார் என்பது தவறான கண்ணோட்டம். நீங்க பாலுவின் தீவிர ரசிகராக இருங்கள். ஆனால் மனோவை கடுமையாக விமர்சனம் செய்வது ஒட்டுமொத்தமாக அவர் பாடிய பாடல்களையும் மறைமுகமாக விமர்சனம் செய்கிறீர்கள் என அர்த்தம்.

in my abipraayam both SPB and Mano are trying to invoke Ghantasaala and SPB is more successful at this.

[PARAMASHIVAN]

in my abipraayam both SPB and Mano are trying to invoke Ghantasaala and SPB is more successful at this.

aha Puthusa oru Ragalaiya aarambichuar! Ghantasala's voice is totally Different to SPB and these singers were in Two different Era !

Flau

Your Telugu expertise required!

[Plum]

SPB did start off trying to imitate Ghantasala - as that was the requirement then in Telugu. Music Director specification kodukkum bOdhE idhu key requirementA veppAr. As he is a fan of Rafi, konjam konjam Rafi styleum theriyum but that was not very prominent. pOga pOga, SPB evolved his own style. Manovukku apdi solla mudiyumA? (Yeah, he evolved the hey shabba muqabla style - adhellaam oru perumaiyaa?). And I dont care about his evolution post mid-90s, as he had done enough damage to IR songs by then. Mano - mannikka mudiyAdha karumbuLLi in IR's career. RAmarajan pada paadalgaL apdinNE oru genrevai sila janam odhukku vekkudhu - idhu nadappu uNmaim hublEyE pAkkalAm - adhula Manovukkum perum pangu uNdu. Thaenmozhi pAttu lyrics ippO gnAbagam illai - oru muRai kEttuttu, mano epdi pAdi irukkArO apdiyE post paNdrEn - adhuvum original lyricsum evLo oththu pOgudhunnu neenga ellOrumE sollunga - assuming we can find the original lyrics. The man has what I call the tongue-tied problem - I have the same problem. adhAvadhu, nAkku nEELAdhu.(Tied to inner mouth). idhanAla, sila vArthaigaL theLivA ucharikka mudiyAdhu. Manokku andha medical condition irukkA illaiyA theriyalai - but andha symptoms mattum theLviA irukku. I cant remember other examples now and have to quote only this trivial one but it should give an indiacation - befiore the movie was released, for quite some time, I used to think it is pandiyanin raajiyathil gujjalaaala. (Radiola promos varum - muzhu pAttu varaaadhu adhanaala chitra portions kekkalai). padam vandhappuRam chitra paadiyadhai vechu dhaan uyaalaalanu therinjudhu. In this case, lyric loss oNNum illai but ipdi pala samplegaL irukku.

FAramu, ivLO menaketturukkEn, innoru id create paNNi innoru vote pottudunga

[Plum]

konjam imagine paNNi pArthEn(kEttEn) - Ghantasala singing "iLamai idhO idhO"...

[HonestRaj]

nerd

avar inga regular illAinnAlum, sinna kounder varumpOthu kooppida solli irukkAr avarOda AsthAna thread'la onnu postREn...

91 end'la irundhu regular'ah inge irukken..

He has actually listed more than two, IIRC Anyways, I'll allocate 0.5 to MMM & 0.5 to SKS.

Current count :
rAjAthi - 2.5 (Nerd / jg / app)
muthumaNi -3 (B(K), venkki, engine, V_S)
sAmi kitta -2.5 (Plum, grouch, ji)

count me in for "muthumaNi mAlai"

I liked Susheela's singing.. yarukkum pidikkalaya
good choice for this one, rather than usual janaki..

no need to mention.. total album starting from IR's "kannupada pogudhayya" till spb's "koondukulla ennai vechu"

[Bala (Karthik)]

Plum
I kind of get what you mean. Mano koral stuff panna madhiri irukkum and his voice is not pleasant on the ears IMO. Neengalum Paramu-vum solra alavukku mosamilla, avlodhaan. Paramu vera edho fans range ku project panraaru.
And gujjalaala'laam illainga uyyalaala (or) vuyyalaala nu dhaane kekkudhu. Any other example?