Khan Saheb Kamal Haasan's Jamaat/Jeba Koottam/Devasthaanam - Part 8

[kid-glove]

Kamal is anti-hindu, Woody is anti-jew, why is that I'm more worried of P_R being anti-football.

[P_R]

I am proud that I touched ur nerve

Oru kalakkaththathai yERpaduthuradhu dhaanE avarum seyyuraar.
Again I refeat - ippo ellAm avvaLO azhagaana seyyuradhillai.
VR - pArppOm
GM: enna aappOm?

[Bala (Karthik)]

And Sathya, if I am not the authority on who should question what, why is Kamal being demanded to do this and that??? Why is he alone subjected to the demands of the "authority"

[Bala (Karthik)]

Equa
Can you elaborate on why Kamal's films areHindu and generally the point you are making about one being "engaged"? Not sure if I follow

[P_R]

"applies downwards accordingly", "in a way self critical too" ......^
This is about caste *identity*, the mere existence of it, which in my opinion should go. and it starts with my kurupp.

Actually idhai paththi virivA eppayaachum pEsalAm. Actually what is meant by saadhi ozhiyaNum. What are the markers, practices we are talking about? I don't think we engage with this question deeply enough.

[sathya_1979]

No No, no confrontation and all. Unga opinion and understandingof KH neenga sollirukkeenga, I found his view points as shallow and not worthy to pay heed to. avLodhaan. Based on my life experiences, I have formed opinions on certain subjects - Religion, Atheism, Casteism, Balanced Criticism etc. When our POV does not match with others, decentaa hand-shake senjittu poidalaamngradhudhaan ennOda karuththu.
aduththavanga namba POV accept seiyyalEngradhukkaaga veRuppu, virOdham etc etc - I am not for that game. I always know your opinions as well that of others (apdinnu nenachittrukkEn) - Based on what I inferred from ur posts all along. adhu enakku oththu pOgalai. avLodhaan.
maRRapadi respect on you people as well as KH as a "Film Artist" never diminished. Believe it or not, onsappaanyatayam I was a Die-Hard KH fan, started moving away after entry of topics about atheism and Hindu Criticism (Or Maybe when I started realizing that those are being fed through the movies).
namakku pidichcha idolOda views namakkum pidikkaNumnu avasiyam illayE

[P_R]

Kamal is anti-hindu, Woody is anti-jew, why is that I'm more worried of P_R being anti-football.

You Dawkinsian ruffian!

[sathya_1979]

And Sathya, if I am not the authority on who should question what, why is Kamal being demanded to do this and that??? Why is he alone subjected to the demands of the "authority"

Rational kittErundhu "Balanced" criticism dhaan edhirpaakkaRom, criticismE paNNa koodaadhunnu solla endha rightum illainu enakku theriyum

[sathya_1979]

Actually idhai paththi virivA eppayaachum pEsalAm. Actually what is meant by saadhi ozhiyaNum. What are the markers, practices we are talking about? I don't think we engage with this question deeply enough.

Brilliant. idhukkudhaan ungaLa maadhiri padichavanga vEnumgradhu. Define the parameters - Then, we shall define the system. nalladhu nadandhaa sari. idhai paRRi pEsumbOdhu revolution paRRi kalki la padichcha oru line dhaan nyaabagaththukku varudhu - The meaning of Revolution in today's world - It is not about creating equality but mere transfer of power from one group to another group.

[Bala (Karthik)]

Actually idhai paththi virivA eppayaachum pEsalAm. Actually what is meant by saadhi ozhiyaNum. What are the markers, practices we are talking about? I don't think we engage with this question deeply enough.

Yes, and racism, conditioning, prejudice etc...
Have you read outlook S.Anand's piece on himself and his wife (about his Brahmin background)? We may or may not share his views on undoing everything to rid oneself of that identity, but I found it interesting.

Is it ok to be a cultural Brahmin (food, baashai to kids etc)? Does that identity (however mild and moderate) come with so much baggage and conditioning that some kind of subtle elitism and perception of superiority creep in? Is the exhibition of these markets harmless or offensive to victims?