Nadigar Thilagam Sivaji Ganesan Part 11

[Rangarajan nambi]

Not exactly Nambi Sir. It is true that Sivaji despised fighting scenes in movies openly in interviews. But in late 60s and early 70s ,he did some amazing scenes in this genre also. I am serious and you know me unless I am convinced ,I wont talk it out. I recommend some scenes. Sivantha Man Jail break fight Scene, Raja's Randha Singh fight Scene. The beauty is that he was able to bring out the spirit,energy, humanness(showed reactions&Anxieties),inviting challenge gesture,Figher's rhythm and Grace. It is true that they are few in numbers but they stand apart. Sivaji can not be labelled and he proved his mettle in all areas(Never got caught in image trap and tried his hands everywhere with great success) . Thats why even today, we are all mesmerised.

Thats why I am really surprised. Knowing your calibre , I thought you are one of the best judges of deciphering Sivaji's skills and attributes. Disappointing that you are vouching for his fighting , stunt skills ! You also know that he tried as a Karate exponent in Dharmaraja at an age well beyond his reach and you know the outcome . Definitely, Sivaji doeesnt have any fighting capabilities, especially stunts or the briskness that needs to be displayed . It will be more of comic scene only .

[iufegolarev]

Thats why I am really surprised. Knowing your calibre , I thought you are one of the best judges of deciphering Sivaji's skills and attributes. Disappointing that you are vouching for his fighting , stunt skills ! You also know that he tried as a Karate exponent in Dharmaraja at an age well beyond his reach and you know the outcome . Definitely, Sivaji doeesnt have any fighting capabilities, especially stunts or the briskness that needs to be displayed . It will be more of comic scene only .

Dear Mr.RN

We are very glad that you are enjoying the comedy, time and again like how we enjoy the comedy of your favourite actor (whoever it may be) !
That's what every actor is supposed to do. Make a viewer to watch be it is for appreciation or depreciation. In that way, both the actors (your favourite and our favourite) has succeeded.

Just enjoy the comedy buddy..

[Gopal.s]

Thats why I am really surprised. Knowing your calibre , I thought you are one of the best judges of deciphering Sivaji's skills and attributes. Disappointing that you are vouching for his fighting , stunt skills ! You also know that he tried as a Karate exponent in Dharmaraja at an age well beyond his reach and you know the outcome . Definitely, Sivaji doeesnt have any fighting capabilities, especially stunts or the briskness that needs to be displayed . It will be more of comic scene only .

You are repeatedly judgemental and quoting Dharma Raja. All I am requesting is that have a look at Kathavarayan Malyudhdham, sivantha Man Jail break scene, Fight with Randha in Raja. You will get your feel on Sivaji.He had all that you mentioned and exhibited it . Before Dharma raja ,he fractured his limbs during the shooting of Thatcholi Ambu(Malayalam) and hence this outcome. I agree that he was a miscast in Dharma Raja.I definitely saw sivaji's Agility,Energy,Style and skill in some Fight Scenes in late 60s and early 70s. But Sivaji despised those scenes and felt that he is not required to do such scenes.

[iufegolarev]

You are repeatedly judgemental and quoting Dharma Raja. All I am requesting is that have a look at Kathavarayan Malyudhdham, sivantha Man Jail break scene, Fight with Randha in Raja. You will get your feel on Sivaji.He had all that you mentioned and exhibited it . Before Dharma raja ,he fractured his limbs during the shooting of Thatcholi Ambu(Malayalam) and hence this outcome. I agree that he was a miscast in Dharma Raja.I definitely saw sivaji's Agility,Energy,Style and skill in some Fight Scenes in late 60s and early 70s. But Sivaji despised those scenes and felt that he is not required to do such scenes.

Dear Gopal Sir,

A simple request..!

Please stop pleading !

You know those are desperate measures time and again carried out by few gentlemen. Everybody has their own views. Like how he has his view, we have ours. The way he enjoys the fights sequence of NT as comedy, I am also enjoying all the sequences of his favourite actor (whoever it may be) as comedy. there is nothing wrong in it as long as NT entertains him in some form or the other.

You always, go behind and repeatedly plead...ayya ...paarungayya..dhayaseidhu paarungayya type...!

[Gopal.s]

Dear Gopal Sir,

A simple request..!

Please stop pleading !

You know those are desperate measures time and again carried out by few gentlemen. Everybody has their own views. Like how he has his view, we have ours. The way he enjoys the fights sequence of NT as comedy, I am also enjoying all the sequences of his favourite actor (whoever it may be) as comedy. there is nothing wrong in it as long as NT entertains him in some form or the other.

You always, go behind and repeatedly plead...ayya ...paarungayya..dhayaseidhu paarungayya type...!

Subbu,
This is where you and I differ. I saw almost all movies in Tamil and other languages and know relative merits and de-merits. When someone is opinionated ,I cant leave it unanswered. To justify my stance and I gave him a worthwhile examples.It is his duty to have a look (he has easy access also) and come back with his comments. Nambi and I have no problem. We will settle out. We beg or threaten ,the crux of the argument is same. Eye for Eye is not good to justify your point.Pointing your fingures on others is not an answer for his point. Let me handle it as it is addressed to me in my own way ,leave it to me and Nambi.

[iufegolarev]

Subbu,
This is where you and I differ. I saw almost all movies in Tamil and other languages and know relative merits and de-merits. When someone is opinionated ,I cant leave it unanswered. To justify my stance and I gave him a worthwhile examples.It is his duty to have a look (he has easy access also) and come back with his comments. Nambi and I have no problem. We will settle out. We beg or threaten ,the crux of the argument is same. Eye for Eye is not good to justify your point.Pointing your fingures on others is not an answer for his point. Let me handle it as it is addressed to me in my own way ,leave it to me and Nambi.

Oh Please.....handle it ..not an issue at all....

நீங்கள் உலகத்தில் உள்ள அனைத்து திரைப்படங்களையும் பார்த்திருக்கலாம். அதை பற்றி எனக்கு கவலை இல்லை, கேள்வியும் இல்லை, ஐயமும் இல்லை, அக்கரையும் இல்லை, அதை தெரிந்துகொண்டு எந்த பயனும் இல்லை.

இது போல பதிவுகள் வரும்போது...அதற்க்கு நீங்கள் புரியவைகிரேன் பேர்வழி என்று எழுதும்போது அதற்க்கு அந்த பதிவுக்கு உரியவர் மேலும் நடிகர் திலகத்தை மட்டம் தட்டும்போது, அதற்க்கும் தாங்கள் பதில் பதிவு இடும்போது மட்டும் இந்த திரியின் ஓட்டம் உங்களாலோ அல்லது பதிவை இடுபவராலோ பாதிக்கப்படவில்லை. பாதிக்கபடுவதாக உங்களுக்கு தோன்றவில்லை..! இல்லையா ?

ஆனால் நான் ஒரு பதிவு செய்தால் அதற்க்கு இந்த திரியின் ஓட்டம் தடைபடுகிறது, திரியின் பரபரப்பு குறைகிறது, விறுவிறுப்பு மறைகிறது என்று அய்யஹோ உய்யஹோ என்று குதித்துக்கொண்டு பதிவிடுகிறீர்கள்..!

ஏன்...இந்த ஓரவஞ்சனை உங்களுக்கு ! ஊருக்குதான் உபதேசம் !

[mr_karthik]

Thats why I am really surprised. Knowing your calibre , I thought you are one of the best judges of deciphering Sivaji's skills and attributes. Disappointing that you are vouching for his fighting , stunt skills ! You also know that he tried as a Karate exponent in Dharmaraja at an age well beyond his reach and you know the outcome . Definitely, Sivaji doeesnt have any fighting capabilities, especially stunts or the briskness that needs to be displayed . It will be more of comic scene only .

Dear Nambi sir,

Mr. Gopal has posted his view and appreciation about the fighting scene of 'Thangaikkaga', which is posted here by Vasudevan sir to view by everybody. It is an open evidence to watch the fighting skill of NT in that scene. Without talking about that fighting scene of Thangaikkaga, why you purposely dragging Dharmaraja here?.

If he faled in Dharmaraja means, we should not appreciate his skill in Thangaikkaga also. Is it...?.

[vasudevan31355]

தலைவர் புகழ் பாடும் நம் ஒய்.ஜி.மகேந்திரன்.

(சினிமா எக்ஸ்பிரஸ் 16,ஆகஸ்ட் 2013)

[Gopal.s]

Oh Please.....handle it ..not an issue at all....

நீங்கள் உலகத்தில் உள்ள அனைத்து திரைப்படங்களையும் பார்த்திருக்கலாம். அதை பற்றி எனக்கு கவலை இல்லை, கேள்வியும் இல்லை, ஐயமும் இல்லை, அக்கரையும் இல்லை, அதை தெரிந்துகொண்டு எந்த பயனும் இல்லை.

இது போல பதிவுகள் வரும்போது...அதற்க்கு நீங்கள் புரியவைகிரேன் பேர்வழி என்று எழுதும்போது அதற்க்கு அந்த பதிவுக்கு உரியவர் மேலும் நடிகர் திலகத்தை மட்டம் தட்டும்போது, அதற்க்கும் தாங்கள் பதில் பதிவு இடும்போது மட்டும் இந்த திரியின் ஓட்டம் உங்களாலோ அல்லது பதிவை இடுபவராலோ பாதிக்கப்படவில்லை. பாதிக்கபடுவதாக உங்களுக்கு தோன்றவில்லை..! இல்லையா ?

ஆனால் நான் ஒரு பதிவு செய்தால் அதற்க்கு இந்த திரியின் ஓட்டம் தடைபடுகிறது, திரியின் பரபரப்பு குறைகிறது, விறுவிறுப்பு மறைகிறது என்று அய்யஹோ உய்யஹோ என்று குதித்துக்கொண்டு பதிவிடுகிறீர்கள்..!

ஏன்...இந்த ஓரவஞ்சனை உங்களுக்கு ! ஊருக்குதான் உபதேசம் !

அட பாவி,
சத்திரியன் பட பன்னீர் செல்வம் போல நான் சமர்த்தாக uniform கழட்டி விட்டு ,எல்லோருடனும் அமைதியுடன் வாழ எண்ணினாலும், திலகன் போல என்னை uniform போட வைத்துதான் நீ ஓய்வாய் போல. ஏன் இந்த கொலை வெறி உனக்கு?

[Gopal.s]

Vasu,
A good timely posting. Thanks.